培養才藝對升大學的影響－以TYP樣本為例

THE EFFECT OF CULTIVATING ART AND TALENT SKILL ON COLLEGE OUTCOMES: EVIDENCE FROM TAIWAN YOUTH PROJECT

劉家樺(Chia-Hua Liu)

《經濟論文》 47卷4期 (2019/12) Pp. 571-611

摘要

隨著高等教育擴張，民眾關注教育成就的重點已從上大學轉為上好大學。多元入學的實施提升非考試成績對升學的影響。本文以「台灣青少年計畫」，檢視培養才藝決定因素及培養才藝對升大學的影響，其中升大學分為上大學及上好大學。在培養才藝決定因素分析中發現，基測成績與運動舞蹈、作文演講才藝呈負向、正向關係，顯示認知能力與運動舞蹈和作文演講才藝呈替代和互補關係。其次，在控制才藝天份和各項其他變數下，培養才藝和基測成績皆與上好大學呈正向關係，其中作文演講才藝與上好大學之正向關係最明確。另外，培養才藝與基測成績交乘項和上好大學呈正向關係，隱含在多元入學制度下，同時具有優良才藝和基測成績表現者較能獲得較佳的升學結果。

關鍵字

才藝 ； 培養才藝 ； 教育成就 ； 國立大學 ； 國立頂尖大學

並列摘要

With the expansion of higher education, the public attention on educational attainment has shifted from entering college to entering a good college. The implementation of the multi-channel admission program raises the impact of non-test scores on college outcomes. Using the Taiwan Youth Project, this paper examines determinants of cultivating art and talent skill (cultivating skill), and effects of cultivating skill on college outcomes. In analyzing determinants of cultivating skill, the paper finds that basic competence test scores (BCT scores) are negatively correlated with cultivating sport-and-dance-related skills, and positively correlated with cultivating writing-and-speech-related skills. These findings suggest that the relationship between cognitive ability and sport-and-dance-related skills is substitutional, while the relationship between cognitive ability and writing-and-speech-related skills is complementary. Moreover, after controlling for inherent talent and other characteristics, results indicate that cultivating skills and BCT scores both are positively correlated with entering a good college. Among all skills, the positive correlation between writing-and-speech-related skills and entering a good college is the clearest. Furthermore, the interaction between cultivating skills and BCT scores is positively related to entering a good college, which implies that students who have both decent art and talent performance and good BCT scores may get a better result under the multi-channel admission program.

並列關鍵字

Skills ； Cultivating art and talent skill ； Educational attainment ； National colleges ； Elite national colleges

參考文獻

王錠堯 ( 2003 ) , 「 體育保送制度 」 , 《 運動生理週訊 》 , 150 , https://tinyurl.com/y5reccvx 。 [Wang, D.-Y. (2003), “The System for Sports to Recommend for Admission," Sports Physiology Weekly Newsletter, 150, https://tinyurl.com/y5reccvx.]

王麗雲與游錦雲 ( 2005 ) , 「 學童社經背景與暑期經驗對暑期學習成就進展影響之研究 」 , 《教育研究集刊》 , 51, 1–41, [Wang, L.-Y. and J.-Y. Yuo (2005), “The Influence of Chil- dren's Socioeconomic Status and Summer Experiences on Their Achievement Progress in the Summer," Bulletin of Educational Research, 51, 1–41.]

行政院教育改革審議委員會 ( 1996 ) , 《 行政院教育改革總諮議報告書 》 , 台北 : 行政院 。 [The Advisory Committee of Educational Reform of Executive Yuan (1996), The General Consulting Report on Educational Reform, Taipei: Executive Yuan.]

吳慧瑛 ( 2007 ) , 「 家庭背景與教育成就 - 五個出生世代的比較分析 」 , 《 人口學刊 》 , 34 , 6. 109–143, [Wu, H.-Y. (2007), “Family Background and Educational Achievement in Tai- wan: Changing Trends in Five Cohorts," Journal of Population Studies, 34, 109–143.]

林志成 ( 2013 ) , 「 甄選入學比例 , 提高到 8 成 」 , https://tinyurl.com/y9abuqhq 。 [ Lin , Z.-C. (2013), "The Admission by Recommendation and Screening Is Planned to Raise at Eighty Percentage," https://tinyurl.com/y9abuqhq.]