EEWH與LEED指標相關性之研究 -以集合住宅案例為例

A Measures Of Relationship Of the EEWH and LEED Assessment System for Green Building –Using The Housing as Example

賴淑華(Shu-Hua Lai)

指導教授 ： 郭章淵

朝陽科技大學/設計學院/建築及都市設計研究所/碩士(2011年)

摘要

本研究選取國內20個高層建築集合住宅案例為研究對象，採用綠建築評估系統EEWH與LEED對案例進行評估，探討各案例在EEWH與LEED評估系統得分分佈與項目差異性；為了達成評估有效性，EEWH評估內容採用達成率作為得分計算方式；其次探討各案例在EEWH與LEED各指標所應用之評估項目等級差異性及有無相關性。
就所得案例分析結論如下：1.國內EEWH評估系統區分五等級，指標包含九大指標採基本合格制；美國LEED評估系統區分為四等級，六大項67個指標採得分方式為累積計分評定等級。2.國內案例進行LEED評估系統得分集中於三項目指標，國內案例進行EEWH評估系統得分集中於六指標。3.國內案例以LEED評估系統與EEWH評估系統進行評估，顯示整體是不具相關性；在LEED節水指標與EEWH健康(水資源指標)是具有相關性。

關鍵字

綠建築評估指標 ； 案例評估 ； 綠建築

並列摘要

This study selected 20 high-rise buildings of congregate housing in Taiwan as the subjects, and used green building rating system EEWH and LEED to perform assessments on the subjects to investigate the distribution of scores and difference in assessment criteria of the subjects in EEWH and LEED rating systems. To obtain the assessment of acceptable validity, EEWH used achieving rate for scoring. Moreover, this study also investigated if there is level difference and any correlation among assessment criteria.
The findings are as follows: 1) The EEWH rating system in Taiwan is a 5-grade system including 9 major criteria where basic eligibility criteria are applied; the U.S. LEED assessment system is a 4-grade system including 6 major criteria and 67 indices where total score is used for grade rating; 2) the subjects in Taiwan assessed by LEED rating system obtained the highest scores in 3 criteria, and those assessed by EEWH rating system obtained the highest scores in 6 criteria; 3) the results showed that there is no significant correlation between the overall subjects in Taiwan assessed by LEED rating system and those assessed by EEWH rating system. There is a correlation between the water-saving criterion of LEED and health (water resource criterion) of EEWH.

並列關鍵字

Green building ； Case assessment ； Green building assessment criteria

參考文獻

9.高養安，2009，”台中地區的綠建築發展現況與評估調查”，亞洲大學生物資訊研究所碩士論文。

3.吳明助，2008，”推動綠建築證書與標章提升策略之探討”，中央大學研究所碩士論文。

20.張桂鳯，2005，”永續環境評估系統運用於台灣地區建築物性能評價之研究”， 成功大學建築研究所博士論文。

14.黃輝雄，2006，”高層集合住宅綠建築可行性評估”，成功大學建築研究所碩士論文。

8.林政賢，2004，”綠建築評估指標適用性之研究”，成功大學建築研究所碩士論文。