城市能源轉型與治理實踐：以德國弗萊堡市為例

Urban Energy Transition and Governance Practice: The Case of Freiburg

李宜卿(Yi-Ching Lee)

《問題與研究》 58卷4期 (2019/12) Pp. 69-110

https://doi.org/10.30390/ISC.201912_58(4).0003

摘要

氣候變遷與能源安全揭示了新一波能源轉型的重要性。在此背景下，城市作為全球經濟體系的生產、技術與能源消費的中心，其重要性持續提升。面對氣候與能源轉型議題，城市在何種程度上可以發展出有別於更高層級（國家、全球）的治理策略，成為學界與政策實務關切的重要課題。本文以德國弗萊堡市推動能源轉型經驗為例，聚焦於以下討論：城市或地方層級如何實踐能源轉型歷程？當中發展出哪些地方性的治理活動？以下本文將先回顧能源轉型與氣候治理相關文獻，以及近年對於能源民主概念的討論，來梳理出城市能源治理的重要面向。其次，本文在介紹德國能源轉型的背景概況後，將以弗萊堡市為例，檢視城市於能源轉型歷程中的治理策略。接著，本文將回顧弗萊堡市能源治理經驗，凸顯城市具體回應能源轉型趨勢，與透過地方能源自主帶動治理模式創新的重要性。研究發現，弗萊堡市透過兩種途徑來推動城市能源轉型。一方面，市政府作為管制者與規劃者、供給者與促進者，透過結合多種治理模式，在引導城市能源轉型歷程上扮演重要角色；另方面，公民與能源合作社自主治理，投資地方再生能源計畫，凸顯出轉型歷程中的公眾參與，也是城市能源轉型的重要力量。

關鍵字

城市 ； 能源轉型 ； 治理 ； 能源民主

並列摘要

Climate change and energy security highlight the significance of energy transition. As an important node of production, technology and energy consumption in the world, cities play an important role in the economic and social transformation towards sustainable energy. It has been widely acknowledged as one of the major issues that cities and local governments explore governing strategies different from the higher governance level (national, global) to achieve the energy transition. This paper attempts to answer the following questions: How do the city and local levels implement the energy transition process? What are the major governing strategies during the implementation process in Freiburg, one of the green cities in Germany? Apart from reviewing the development of energy transition and local government system in Germany, this paper discusses the models and strategies of existing urban energy governance and self-governance of citizen energy in Freiburg. The study finds that Freiburg introduces two approaches for urban energy transition. The municipality plays an essential role as regulator and planner, provider, facilitator, and combines different modes of governing to foster urban energy transition. In addition, the self-governance of citizens, energy cooperatives, and the investment at local- or community-based renewable highlight the public participation and their contribution to the transition process.

並列關鍵字

City ； Energy Transition ； Governance ； Energy Democracy

參考文獻

王乾坤，2014，〈德國可再生能源新政策三大趨勢分析〉，http://www.chinaero.com.cn/zxdt/nyzqf/2014/08/147190.shtml，查閱時間：2014/08/26。Wang, Qian-Kun. 2014. “Deguo kezaishengnengyuan xin zhengcesan da qushi fenxi” [Three Trends of New Renewable Energy Policy in Germany]. (Accessed on August 26, 2014).

王琪、唐小莉、陳仁德譯，Franz Alt著，2005，《太陽電力公司—新能源、新就業機會》，台北：新自然主義。Wang, Qi, Xiao-Li Tang and Ren-De Chen, trans., Franz Alt. 2005. Taiyang dianli gongsi: Xin neng yuan, xin jiuye jihui [The Sun Sends us No Bill: New Eenergy, New Job]. Taipei: Green Futures Publisher Co.

李長晏、莊旻達，2008，〈城市治理民主化：一個分析架構的提出〉，《中國地方自治》，61 (11)：27-52。Lee, Chang-Yen and Min Ta Chuang. 2008. “Chengshi zhili minzhuhua: Yige fenxi jiagou de tichu” [Democratization of Urban Governance: An Analytical Framework]. Chong Guo Di Fang Zi Zhi,61(11): 27-52.

李長晏、曾士瑋，2010，〈城市氣候治理理論初探：策略變遷、治理模式與風險評估〉，《城市學學刊》，1 (2)：37-73。Lee, Chang-Yen and Shih-Wei Tseng. 2010. “Chengshi qihou zhili lilun chutan: Celüe bianqian, zhili moshi yu fengxian pinggu” [Preliminary Study on Urban Climate Governance Theory: Strategical Change, Governance Mode and Risk Assessment]. Journal of Urbanology, 1(2): 37-73.

沃邦城區協會(Stadtteilverein Vauban e.V.)，2016，《弗萊堡沃邦區巡禮》，弗萊堡：沃邦城區協會，二版。Stadtteilverein Vauban e.V. 2016. Fulaibao wobang qu xunli [Quartier Vauban – A Guided Tour: The Vision of a Sustainable District Becomes Reality]. Freiburg, Germany: Stadtteilverein Vauban e.V.