The Discontinuation of a Vicious Cycle? The Evolutionary Contour of China's Central-Local Relations, 1978-2018

徐斯勤(S. PHILIP HSU)

《Issues & Studies》 56卷1期 (2020/03) Pp. 1-32

https://doi.org/10.1142/S1013251120400019

摘要

As a retrospective exploration of China's central-local relations over the past four decades of the reform era, this paper argues that since the mid-1990s, relations have evolved with a growing likelihood to break away from the vicious cycle of decentralization and recentralization since 1949. China’s post-reform era started in synchronization with a sweeping move toward decentralization, a trend which generated a myriad of systemic crises that threatened the legitimacy and survival of the regime. Thus, the mid-1990s saw a systematic rollback of decentralization. This rollback is to be understood as a comprehensive scheme of rebalancing rather than a mere replication of pre-reform recentralization. On the other hand, the rebalancing has still occurred in consistence with a cyclical pattern that had characterized the broadly conceived regularity of decentralization and recentralization. While the rebalancing has not been immune from various pathologies, the central state has selected to make contingent and marginal adaptations to cope with the problems instead of shattering the current framework of rebalancing and returning completely to decentralization. Instead of relying solely on original research, this paper will bolster its main argument by conducting a synthetic reasoning from a rich array of extant analyses to sketch out the contours of China's central-local relations in fiscal, investment, and personnel management policy areas during the past four decades.

關鍵字

Central-local relations ； vicious cycle of decentralization and recentralization ； rebalancing ； fiscal policy ； investment policy ； personnel management policy

參考文獻

Bachman, D. (1986). Differing visions of China’s post-Mao economy: The ideas of Chen Yun, Deng Xiaoping, and Zhao Ziyang. Asian Survey, 26(3), 292–321.

Bo, Z. Y. (2002). Chinese provincial leaders: Economic performance and political mobility since 1949. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.

Bo, Z. Y. (2003). The provinces: Training ground for national leaders or a power in their own right? In D. M. Finkelstein & M. Kivlehan (Eds.), China’s leadership in the 21st century: The rise of the fourth generation (pp. 66-117). Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.

Burns, J. (1987). China’s Nomenklatura system. Problems of Communism, 36(5), 36–51.

Chen, J. S. [陳俊松]. (2018). 2018 Difangzhai jinglue: “Zhongshen wenze” lanzhu difang man-gmu juzhai chongdong [2018地方債經略：「終身問責」攔住地方盲目舉債衝動, The coping strategy on local debts in 2018: “Lifetime Accountability” stops local governments’impulse of reckless debt-financing]. Retrieved September 13, 2018 from http://big5.xin-huanet.com/gate/big5/www.xinhuanet.com/fortune/2018-09/13/c_129950651.htm