內生化的制度選擇與長期經濟增長：以河北省縣域地區差距為例，1952～1998

Endogenous Institutions and Economic Growth: An Empirical Evidence Look into the Economic Performance at the County Level in the Hebei Province from 1952~1998

遊五嶽(Wu-Yue You) ； 李飛躍(Fei-Yue Li) ； 張冬(Dong Zhang) ； 劉明興(Ming-Xing Liu)

《中國大陸研究》 62卷2期 (2019/06) Pp. 1-39

https://doi.org/10.30389/MCS.201906_62(2).0001

摘要

帶來經濟持續增長的良好制度往往內生於制度形成的歷史過程，通過挖掘河北省各個縣在抗日戰爭中的革命經歷，我們發現戰爭過程通過影響各個縣政治菁英的實際政治權力，塑造了他們制度選擇的動機和激勵，從而影響了地方的長期經濟增長。並且，由抗戰歷史所塑造的兩個方面實際政治權力對經濟增長的影響是不同的：當由武裝力量和根據地歷史所塑造的地方政治菁英集體行動能力和社會動員能力越強時，經濟的增長績效越好；而如果由上層革命機關分布所塑造的地方政治菁英與上層菁英之間的政治聯繫越緊密時，經濟的增長績效則會變差。

關鍵字

經濟增長 ； 內生化制度 ； 實際政治權力 ； 歷史過程

並列摘要

Institutions good for long-term economic growth are always endogenous to the historical process that it formed. By investigating the conflicts during the Anti-Japanese War in Hebei, we found that the war shaped the de-facto political power of local elites by shaping their choice of institutions and policy, which then influenced the economic performance. We also present that the two sides of the de-facto political power had different impacts on the economic growth. County cadres with stronger capacity in collective action and social mobilization due to the strength of military forces would have incentive to protect property rights and withstand the pressure to extract economic resources excessively. However, county cadres with close connections to the higher-level authority due to the distribution of CCP's committees in the warfare area would extract more economic resources, which in turn led to poorer growth performance.

並列關鍵字

Economic Growth ； Endogenous Institutions ； De-facto Political Power ； Historical Process

參考文獻

中共中央組織部、中共中央黨史研究室、中央檔案館，2000，《中國共產黨組織史資料（1921∼1997）》，北京：中共黨史出版社。Zhonggong zhongyang zuzhibu, zhonggong zhongyang dangshi yanjiushi, zhongyang danganguan. 2000. Zhongguo gongchandang zuzhishi ziliao (1921~1997) [Historical Materials of Chinese Communist Party’s Organizations in Hebei (1921~1997)]. Beijing: Chinese Communist Party’s History Press.

中共河北省委組織部、中共河北省黨史資料徵集編審委員會、河北省檔案局，1990，《中國共產黨河北省組織史資料（1922∼1987）》，河北：河北人民出版社。Zhonggong hebei shengwei zuzhibu, zhonggong hebeisheng dangshi ziliao zhengji bianshen weiyuanhui, hebeisheng danganju. 1990. Zhongguo gongchandang hebeisheng zuzhishi ziliao (1922~1987) [Historical Materials of Chinese Communist Party’s Organizations in Hebei (1922~1987)]. Hebei: Hebei People’ Press.

王友明，2006，《革命與鄉村：解放區土地改革研究：1941∼1948》，上海：上海社會科學院出版社。Wang, You-ming. 2006. Geming yu xiangcun: jiefangqu tudi gaige yanjiu, 1941~1948 [Revolution and Village: Land Reform in Liberated Areas,1941~1948]. Shanghai: Shanghai Social Science Academy Press.

王文劍、覃成林，2008，〈地方政府行為與財政分權增長效應的地區性差異：基於經驗分析的判斷、假說及檢驗〉，《管理世界》，1：9-21。Wang, Wen-jian, Cheng-lin Tan. 2008. “Difang zhengfu xingwei yu caizheng fenquan zengzhang xiaoying de diquxing chayi: jiyu jingyan fenxi de panduan, jiashuo ji jianyan”[Regional Variations in Local Governments’ Behaviour and Effects of Fiscal Decentralization: Evaluation, Hypothesis and Evidence Base on Empirical Analysis]. Management World, 1: 9-21.

王賢彬、徐現祥，2008，〈地方官員來源、去向、任期與經濟增長：來自中國省長省委書記的證據〉，《管理世界》，3：16-26。Wang, Xian-bin, and Xian-xiang Xu. 2008.“Difang guanyuan laiyuan, quxiang, renqi yu jingji zengzhang: laizi zhongguo shengzhang shengwei shuji de zhengju”[The Career Paths of Local Cadres and Economic Growth: Evidence from Provincial Governors and Party Secretaries]. Management World, 3: 16-26.