中共對外使用武力之動態衝突抉擇模式：以1962年中印邊境戰爭為例

由於中國崛起以及近年與日本、印度、越南及菲律賓等周邊國家的衝突，有關中共對外使用武力的研究再度引起學界的關注。本文研究問題是：中共對外使用武力的原因眾多，是否可以將諸多原因概念化？中共對外使用武力行為是否變化無常、不可解釋或是僅能靜態分析？如否，何種機制促使中共使用武力？使用武力的最終決策選擇（衝突規模）會受到哪些因素的制約或影響，而呈現動態的衝突抉擇樣式？本文借鑑國際關係領域的預防性動機理論、動態差異理論、聯盟理論及窗戶邏輯、心理學的認知理論、經濟學的展望理論及外交政策分析的多元啟發等相關理論的核心概念，透過將中共對外使用武力原因的概念化過程，以預防性動機為主軸，希冀建構一個「中共對外使用武力之動態衝突抉擇模式」，並且以1962年中印邊境戰爭為案例，採取過程追蹤與類型學等研究方法，用以驗證本模式之適用性。本文透過個案分析，證實了兩個研究假設：（一）中共是出於防止周邊權力地位衰退的預防性動機，而對挑戰其周邊權力地位的國家使用武力；（二）中共使用武力的預防性動機強弱，會影響其最終決策選擇，而呈現動態的衝突抉擇樣式。由此，也初步驗證了本模式的適用性。

關鍵字

中共對外使用武力；動態衝突抉擇模式；預防性動機；中印邊境戰爭

並列摘要

Due to the rise of China and its rekindled conflicts with neighboring countries like Japan, India, Vietnam, and the Philippines in recent years, the study on Communist China's external use of force has once again attracted much academic attention. This thesis's research questions are: there are numerous causes for Communist China's external use of force, could all these causes be conceptualized? Are Communist China's external uses of force capricious? unexplainable? or could only be analyzed statically? If not, what mechanism facilitates Communist China's final decision for the use of force? What factors would limit or influence the final decision to use force (the scale of the conflict) to exhibit a dynamic conflict decision-making pattern? This thesis draws on the core concepts of various theories such as the preventive motivation theory, dynamic differentials theory, alliance theory and window logic in international relations, cognitive theory in psychology, prospect theory in economics, and poliheuristic theory in foreign policy analysis. Through the conceptualization of the causes for Communist China's external use of force, the author wanted to construct a ＂dynamic conflict decision making pattern for Communist China's external use of force＂ along the axis of preventive motivation. The 1962 Sino-Indian Border War was selected as a case study and was analyzed using both the process-tracing and typology methods to examine the applicability of this pattern. By way of the case study, the two following research hypotheses were verified: First, Communist China's use of force against neighboring countries that challenged its authority and position in the region were caused by preventive motivations to prevent any decline of its regional status. Second, the final decision for Communist China's external use of force was influenced by the strength of its preventive motivations and exhibited a dynamic conflict decision-making pattern. Therefore, the applicability of this pattern was also preliminarily validated.

並列關鍵字

Communist China's External Use of Force ； Dynamic Conflict Decision-Making Pattern ； Preventive Motivations ； Sino-Indian Border War

參考文獻

人民出版社編，1962，第2版，《中印邊界問題（增訂版）》，北京：人民。People@@$$s Publishing House. 1962. Version 2. Zhongyin bianjie wenti, zengding ban [Sino-Indian Border Issue, updated version]. Beijing: People@@$$s Publishing House.

Google Scholar

中共中央文獻研究室編，1997，《周恩來年譜：1949~1976（中卷）》，北京：中央文獻。The Central Committee of the Communist Party of Chin Literature research room. 1997. Zhouenlai nianpu:1949~1976, zhongjuan [Zhou Enlai@@$$s Chronology: 1949~1976, middle volume]. Beijing: Central Literature.

Google Scholar

中華人民共和國外交部、外交史研究室編，1993，《周恩來外交活動大事記》，北京：世界知識。The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People@@$$s Republic of China, and the Department of Diplomatic History. 1993. Zhouenlai waijiao huodong dashiji [Zhou Enlai’s Diplomatic Events]. Beijing: World Knowledge.

Google Scholar

王宏緯，2009，《當代中印關係述評》，北京：中國藏學。Wang, Hong-wei. 2009. Dangdai zhongyin guanxi shuping [A Review of Contemporary Sino-Indian Relations]. Beijing: China Tibetology.

Google Scholar

王宏緯、王至亭譯，Karunakar Gupta著，1990，《中印邊界秘史》，北京：中國藏學。Wang, Hong-wei, and Wang Zhi-ting, trans. Karunakar Gupta. 1990. Zhongyin bianjie mishi [The Hidden History of the Sino-Indian Frontier]. Beijing: China Tibetology.

Google Scholar

國際替代計量

中共對外使用武力之動態衝突抉擇模式：以1962年中印邊境戰爭為例

全文下載

主題瀏覽