「勞資衝突」是必然，還是偶然？從結構化理論探討台灣企業勞資衝突之歷程研究

Are Industrial Conflicts Inevitable or Fortuitous? -A Process Research on Industrial Conflicts in Taiwanese Enterprises from the Perspective of Structuration Theory

李怡慧(I-Hui Lee) ； 吳建明(Chien-Ming Wu) ； 林尚平(Shang-Ping Lin)

《臺大管理論叢》 29卷3期 (2019/12) Pp. 83-124

https://doi.org/10.6226/NTUMR.201912_29(3).0003

摘要

「勞資衝突」議題攸關台灣產業經濟發展，但檢視現有學術文獻，除了論文篇數不多，論文發展走向也有一些值得商榷之處。例如，研究主題偏重「勞資爭議事件」而少談「勞資衝突歷程」；研究對象以「企業與工會」為主，較少觸及「管理者與勞工」；研究觀點趨向從「資方結構層面」或「勞工行動面向」的單一角度論述等。這些情況，無形限縮對於此地「勞資衝突」問題的理解。為此，本研究就個案勞資衝突歷程，進行包括企業、工會、管理者、勞工等觀察。同時採取「結構化理論」作為分析架構，藉以探求更深層的勞資衝突發展內涵。本研究希望據此重新思考：「勞資衝突」是企業無法避免的宿命，還是人為行動介入所致。

關鍵字

勞資衝突 ； 結構化理論 ； 工會 ； 勞工 ； 歷程研究

並列摘要

＂Industrial Conflict＂ phenomenon has been common in practice in the business world. How to cope with this issue has become important in the development of Taiwanese industries and economy. For reasons stated above, the study explores cases of industrial conflict in Taiwanese enterprises. Moreover, in order to expand the limited existing sources from single viewpoints of the ＂employer＂ structure or ＂labor＂ action, this study also uses an interactive perspective with the support of structuration theory as the analytical framework to explore the comprehensive dispute process and main reasons of industrial conflicts. Finally, this study aims to disclose facts about the forming process of industrial conflicts and relevant influential factors, and whether these conflicts are the unavoidable fate for organizations or could have been an engineered consequence by interrelated actors.

並列關鍵字

industrial conflict ； structuration theory ； labor union ； labor ； process research

參考文獻

中時電子報，2017，張忠謀擔憂台灣組工會門檻低恐影響企業營運，https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20170626004860-260410?chdtv，搜尋日期：2017 年 8 月 7 日。(Chinatimes.com. 2017. Morris Chang is worried that the low threshold of Taiwan’s trade unions will affect business operations. https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20170626004860-260410?chdtv. Accesse. Aug. 7, 2017.)

王維，2011，國內外勞資衝突管理研究綜述，商業時代，2 期：86-88。(Wang, Wei. 2011. A summary of researches on industrial conflict management at home and abroad. Business Management, 2: 86-88.)

朱力，2006，變遷之痛：轉型期的社會失範研究，北京，中國：社會科學文獻出版社。(Zhu, Li. 2006. Suffer from Changing: An Anomie Research in Chinese Social Transition. Beijing, China: Social Science Academic Press.)

李廣科與李祿堂，2010，基於利益表達的農民工行為失範的制度解釋，電子科技大學學報，12 卷 1 期：56-59。(Li, Guang-Ke, and Li, Lu-Tang. 2010. Institutional explanation of peasant workers anomie based on benefit claim. Journal of UESTC (Social Science Edition), 12 (1): 56-59.)

洪綺純，2010，企業購併後勞資衝突及衝突解決個案研究－以 C公司為例，國立中正大學勞工所未出版之碩士論文，嘉義，台灣。(Hung, Chi-Chun. 2010. A Research of Industrial Cconflict and Reconciliation of Post - acquistition Companies - a case study of a C corporation. Unpublished master’s thesis of Department of Labor Relations, National Chung Cheng University, Chiayi, Taiwan.)