Title

探討台灣目前發展國際醫療行銷策略與外籍病患就醫選擇因素間之差異

Translated Titles

The Gaps between International Medical Marketing Strategy and Factors of Foreign Customers' Hospital Selection in Taiwan

DOI

10.6831/TMU.2011.00007

Authors

林怡吟

Key Words

國際醫療 ; 行銷策略 ; 就醫選擇 ; international medical services ; marketing strategy ; patients’ hospital selection

PublicationName

臺北醫學大學醫務管理學研究所學位論文

Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

2011年

Academic Degree Category

碩士

Advisor

郭乃文

Content Language

繁體中文

Chinese Abstract

行政院經建會與衛生署,於2007年將「醫療服務國際化旗艦計畫」列為「2015經濟發展願景第一階段三年衝刺計畫」,2009年再提出健康照護升值白金方案行動計畫-醫療服務國際化旗艦計畫(2009-2012),明訂積極推動國際醫療服務的政策。 本研究旨在瞭解台灣發展國際醫療至今,國際醫療顧客及醫療院所對來台接受服務的原因與相關考量,分析已在國內推行國際醫療院所之行銷策略,探討其運用模式的優劣;以作為台灣發展國際醫療服務之參考。 本研究以橫斷性研究並採自填式結構問卷進行分析,客制化設計符合所需之英語問卷內容。研究對象為近年曾來台就醫的國際人士以及已推行國際醫療之醫療院所。國際醫療顧客共發出59份,有效回收53份,回收率為89.8%;醫療機構發出37份,有效回收33份,回收率為89.2%。資料處理使用SPSS18.0版軟體,經以卡方檢定(Chi-square test) 和事後比較-Scheffe法進一步進行統計分析,主要的結果如下: 一、在國際醫療顧客方面:選擇國家的考量是「醫療水準」,選擇醫院的考量是「醫師口碑」;就醫原因以居住地「技術不足」為多數,「親友介紹」為最主要的訊息管道,在台期間生活上的困難為「語言」,期待台灣應加強的也是「語言」,並同意台灣醫療收費「低很多」,對整體的滿意情形是「非常滿意」。 二、在推展國際醫療的醫療院所對顧客的選擇認知方面:選擇國家的考量是「語言溝通」,選擇醫院的考量是「醫師口碑」;在就醫經驗裡,來台的就醫原因以居住地當地「費用過高」為多數,「親友介紹」為最主要的訊息管道,在台期間生活上的困難為「語言」。 三、國際醫療顧客及發展國際醫療的醫療院所,在就醫選擇考量因素有差異的項目為:國家的「醫療水準」、醫院的「國際認證」、在來台期間生活上的困難為「文化」因素、應加強項目則是「服務」因素。 四、提供者現行的國際醫療定位及行銷組合策略:參與本研究以醫學中心居多,地理位置以北區為主,國際醫療組織層級以任務編組為多數。現行提供者多以地域、族群及疾病三選項中之二項,來重疊規劃目標市場,目前的客源以自行連絡及平台轉介為主。與異業合作及參與各類活動為主要的通路,收費落點多符合專案工作小組制定的健保1.7倍,屬低價位,推廣定位則以「配合政府」及「靜觀同業」的策略者為多數。 研究者根據以上研究結果,提出建議以作為台灣發展國際醫療服務之參考。

English Abstract

Taiwan, situated in an environment of globalization and industry-liberalization, and with advanced medical techniques, is working hard to promote international medical services (IMS), which is an important approach that will allow Taiwan to upgrade its industry development. Therefore, actively promoting IMS has been listed as a priority by Taiwan’s Council for Economic Planning and Development in its project called “The First Phase of Three-Year Sprint Plan of 2015 Economic Development Outlook – Industrial Development Package”. Although Taiwan has started to promote IMS in 2007 through the “International Medical Ad Hoc Management Center” established by the “Non-governmental Hospital & Clinics Association”, IMS is yet still in the developmental stage. In order to promote the industry more completely, it is necessary to evaluate in depth the possibility of strategic development of IMS in Taiwan. Consequently, this study focuses on two key points. First, to explore the reasons, based on previous experiences, why foreign patients received medical treatment in Taiwan. Second, to further analyze marketing strategies of domestic hospitals that have developed IMS, and then to discuss the pros and cons of their strategies, in order to determine more constructive recommendations to develop better IMS in Taiwan. A cross-sectional study and volitional questionnaire for clients will be used for analysis in this research. A custom-made English questionnaire is designed to meet our needs. The objects of study are foreigners who have come to Taiwan to receive medical treatment during the past three years as well as the hospitals that have already promoted IMS. 59 questionnaires were distributed to foreign patients and 53 were retrieved (with a retrieval rate of 89.8%). Medical institutions distributed 37 questionnaires and 33 were retrieved (with a retrieval rate of 89.2%). For data processing, Chi-square test and Scheffe were used for further statistical analysis via the commercial software SPSS version 18. The main results are: 1. For foreign patients: The main consideration in choosing a country for medical treatment is its “medical standard”, and the consideration in choosing a hospital is in the “reputation of doctors”. The primary reason in applying for medical treatment is “a lack of technique” in the place of residence. The main information channel is through “relatives and friends”. Difficulty faced while living in Taiwan is mainly due to “language” and the foreigners also expect Taiwanese to improve their “language skill”. They agreed that the cost for Taiwan medical treatment is “pretty low”. The overall impression is “very satisfied”. 2. For the patients of medical establishments which promoting IMS: The main consideration in choosing a country for medical treatment is “language”. The consideration in choosing hospital is in the “reputation of doctors”. The primary reason in applying for medical treatment in Taiwan is because of “high cost” of medical treatment in their place of residence. Primary information channel is through “relatives and friends”. The main difficulty of living in Taiwan is also “language”. 3. The divergences of consideration medical apply between foreign patients and patients from medical institutions promoting IMS: “medical standard” of the country, “international authentication” of the hospital. The difficulty of living in Taiwan is mainly “culture difference”. “Service” is the main aspect should be improved. 4. Strategy of current IMS position and marketing combination for survey providers: Establishments which involve in this research is mainly medical centers in north Taiwan. Their level of international medical organization is particularly mission organizing. Current survey providers mostly plan the target market by two of the three aspects which are residential area, population and disease. Current patients were mainly from actively connection and medical system transferring. The primary approaching is cooperating with different industries and attending varies activities. The charge is conformed to 1.7-fold of the charge of National health insurance established by specialized work team which is regarding as low price. Promoting strategies are mostly “co-operating with the government” and “observing other medical services institution”. Basing on this study, the results can provide some valuable opinions and advices for developing IMS of Taiwan.

Topic Category 醫藥衛生 > 醫院管理與醫事行政
公共衛生學院 > 醫務管理學研究所
社會科學 > 管理學
Reference
  1. 汪志堅(2010)。消費者行為。臺北:全華。
    連結:
  2. 吳彬安(2008)。我國發展健康保健旅遊可行性模式之探討。國立臺灣大學管理學院碩士在職專班高階公共管理組碩士論文,臺北市。
    連結:
  3. 吳俊賢(2008)。台灣發展醫療旅遊商業模式初探研究。國立臺灣大學醫療機構管理研究所碩士論文,臺北市。
    連結:
  4. 許博欽(2009)。發展國際醫療的策略導入分析。國立臺灣大學管理學院碩士在職專班會計與管理決策組,臺北市。
    連結:
  5. 洪啟元(2009)。醫學美容消費族群對觀光醫療之行為動機。亞洲大學經營管理學系碩士論文,臺中市。
    連結:
  6. 周天給(2005)。台灣外籍新娘對婦產科診所就醫評價之研究。臺北醫學大學醫務管理研究所在職專班碩士論文。
    連結:
  7. 張沅合(2008)。醫療機構服務國際化競爭優勢之研究。亞洲大學經營管理研究所碩士論文,臺中市。
    連結:
  8. 張廣赦(2007)。台灣現行醫療行銷之商業倫理探究。國立中央大學哲學研究所碩士論文,桃園縣。
    連結:
  9. 黃燕鳳(2008)。健檢機構之消費者需求與行銷策略之研究。國立台灣大學公共衛生學院醫療機構管理研究,臺北市。
    連結:
  10. 楊美惠(2008)。台灣發展觀光醫療產業之行銷策略研究。國立臺灣大學管理學院商學研究所碩士論文,臺北市。
    連結:
  11. 楊雅婷(2010)。國際醫療虛實整合經營模式分析。臺北醫學大學醫務管理學系碩士班碩士論文論文,臺北市。
    連結:
  12. 蔣哲輝(2008)。日本民眾對醫療觀光產品認知重要性考量因素與各國認知表現之比較。國立臺灣師範大學人類發展與家庭學系碩士論文,臺北市。
    連結:
  13. 蕭 菁(2009)。旅台外籍人士就醫期望就醫感受與整體滿意度關係之探討。北護醫護科技期刊11卷3期。
    連結:
  14. Adrian Cooper, Alan Wilson, Keith Edmonds & Pablo Astorga (2007). Travel & Tourism
    連結:
  15. & Tourism Council.
    連結:
  16. Anna Garcia Altes. (2005). Annals of Tourism Reserch, Vol.32, No.1, pp.266-268
    連結:
  17. Annette B. Ramirez de Arellano. (2007). Patients without borders: the emergence of medical
    連結:
  18. Law Perspectives pp.1-4
    連結:
  19. Chew Ging Lee. (2010). Health care and tourism: Evidence from Singapore. Tourism
    連結:
  20. Christophe Segouin, Brian Hodges & Pierre-Henri Brechat. (2005). Globalization in health care:
    連結:
  21. is international standardization of quality a step toward outsourcing? Internaional Journal
    連結:
  22. for Quality in Health Care, 17(4), pp.277-279.
    連結:
  23. Devon M. Herrick. (2007). Medical Tourism: global competition in health care. National Center of Policy Analysis No.304
    連結:
  24. Harriet hutson Gray & Susan Cartier Poland. (2008). Medical Tourism: Crossing Borders to Access Health Care. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal Vol.18, No.2, pp.193-201
    連結:
  25. Ian Yeoman, Colin Munro and Una McMahon-Beattie. (2006). Tomorrow’s: World, consumer and tourist. Journal of Vacation Marketing, 12; 174-190
    連結:
  26. graduate-patient communication: A qualitative analysis of perceived barriers. Academic
    連結:
  27. Lydia L. Gan & James R. Frederick (2011). Consumers’ attitudes toward medical tourism
    連結:
  28. Norra MacReady. (2007). Developing countries court medical tourists. World Report Vol 369.
    連結:
  29. value. Medical Tourism, Deloitte pp.3-29
    連結:
  30. Peta S. Cook. (2008). What is health and medical tourism? The annual conference of the
    連結:
  31. Australian Sociological Association, 2 to 5 December 2008. The University of Melbourne, Victoria.
    連結:
  32. Boomers will Change Health Care. American Hospital Association.
    連結:
  33. Rupa Chanda. (2002). Trade in health services. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 80(2);
    連結:
  34. travel. The McKinsey Quarterly.
    連結:
  35. Vinay Kumar Singh.(2011). Public policies for facilitating medical to industry in Asis. Fourth
    連結:
  36. World Health Organizaiton, WHO.,(2008), Http://www.who.inten2008.05.20
    連結:
  37. 參考文獻
  38. 中文文獻
  39. 石曜堂(2008)。第八次全國科學技術會議北部預備會議
  40. http://www.nsc.gov.tw/pla/tc/8th/doc/n_topic1.doc
  41. 王榛驛(2007)。醫療觀光 正夯,Taiwan News。
  42. 江國楊(2006)。我國健康觀光發展之策略研究。國立台北護理學院旅遊健康研究所碩士論文。
  43. 宋欣怡(2001)。民眾就醫選擇資訊的潛在需求研究。國立台灣大學醫療機構管理研究所碩士論文,臺北市。
  44. 吳明彥(2007)。醫療服務國際化之價值鏈(Value-chain)如何建立。台灣私立醫療院所協會「國際醫療與兩岸醫療業務推展高峰論壇」,中國醫藥大學,台中市。
  45. 李炫昇(2008)。國際醫療與卓越醫療在關節重建的展望。長庚醫誌。
  46. 張煥禎、張威國(2007)。醫療行銷管理學。臺北:華杏。
  47. 郭建良(2007)。健康保健旅遊,科技化服務業的新視界。工研院。
  48. 陳柏年(2009)。知覺風險與人口統計特性對行為意向與服務品質期望之探討-以陸客來台醫療觀光為例。私立輔仁大學餐旅管理學系在職專班碩士論文,新北市。
  49. 陳就學、許丁宦(2007)。科特勒帶你發現新亞洲。臺北:聯經。
  50. 陳楚杰(1992)。醫院組織與管理。臺北:宏瀚。
  51. 陳錫銘(2008)。臺灣醫療旅遊產業創新服務之策略研究。國立交通大學高階主管管理學程碩士班碩士論文,新竹市。
  52. 陳世晉(2002)。企業國際策略聯盟對消費者認知行為之影響研究。私立中國文化大學商學院國際企業管理所碩士論文,臺北市。
  53. 黃幸悅(2006)。醫療觀光產業--台灣找到新利基。理財週刊。
  54. 楊承浩(2006)。在台外籍人士生活型態、購物地點對消費行為影響之研究。大葉大學國際企業管理學系碩士班碩士論文,彰化縣。
  55. 葉日武(1997)。行銷學:理論與實務。臺北市:前程企管。
  56. 劉馥瑤(2009)。台灣發展國際醫療旅遊競爭力與策略評估之研究。真理大學休閒遊憩事業學系碩士班,新北市。
  57. 樊泰翔(2008)。國際保健旅遊創新經營模式之研究--以國內某醫學中心為例。國立陽明大學醫務管理研究所碩士論文,臺北市。
  58. 鄭超仁(2004)。牙科門診病患就醫選擇之探討-以花蓮縣為例。國立東華大學企業管理系所碩士論文,花蓮縣。
  59. 蔡素玲(2007)。讓顧客走進來醫療走出去。臺北市:台灣經濟論衡,5 (10),16-38。
  60. 英文文獻
  61. Navigating the Path Ahead - The 2007 Travel & Tourism Economic Research. World Travel
  62. tourism. International Journal of Health Services, Vol.37, No.1 pp.193-198.
  63. Bruce Patsner. (2008). Medical Tourism: A serious business undergoing serious change. Health
  64. Management 31(2010) pp.486-488.
  65. Janson Yap, Sim Siew Chen & Nelson Nones (2008). Medical tourism: the Asian chapter.
  66. Deloitte pp.1-9
  67. Javalgi, R. G. Rao, S. R. & Thomas, E. G. (1991). Choosing a Hospital : Analysis of Consumer Tradeoffs, Journal of Health Care Marketing, 11(1), 12-22.
  68. Kelly A. Dorgan, Forrest Lang, Michael Floyd & Evelyn Kemp (2009). International medical
  69. Medicine, Vol.84, No.11 1567-1575
  70. pp.1849-1850.
  71. Paul H. Keckley & Howard R. Underwook (2008). Medical Tourism-consumers in search of
  72. Prema Nakra (2011). Could medical tourism aid health-care delivery? The futurist Washington:
  73. Mar/Apr. Vol.45, Iss 2; pp.23-24
  74. Richard Afable, Beth Averbeck, ronDziedzicki & Art Nichols (2007). When I’m 64: How
  75. 158-163.
  76. Tilman Ehrbeck, Ceani Guevara & Paul D. Mango.(2008). Mapping the market for medical
  77. Annual International Conference on Public Policy and Management. SSRN Working Paper
  78. Series.