安全研究的個體化：個人當兵經驗如何影響臺灣防衛決心

Security Studies Towards Individuals' Attitude: Military Experience and Support for Self-Defense in Taiwan

陳方隅(Fang-Yu Chen) ； 王宏恩(Austin Horng-En Wang) ； 吳冠昇(Charles K.S. Wu) ； 葉耀元(Yao-Yuan Yeh)

《問題與研究》 61卷3期 (2022/09) Pp. 145-172

https://doi.org/10.30390/ISC.202209_61(3).0004

摘要

臺灣民眾自我防衛的決心，對於我國國防及東亞區域和平皆有重大影響。尤其是在面對可能的兩岸衝突狀況下，了解臺灣民眾的自我防衛意願，與國家安全息息相關。然而，如何解釋臺灣民眾自我防衛決心的差異，在現存的國際關係文獻裡面的討論有限。我們認為，民眾在理性計算是否願意參戰時，過去的從軍經驗是心理上最直接仰賴的資訊，因此從軍經驗的好壞，理論上會影響民眾的自我防衛決心。本文把從軍經驗分成三個面向，包括軍種、覺得軍事訓練對上戰場的有用程度、以及從軍時與長官的相處狀況，並於2018年7月委託政治大學PollcracyLab執行樣本數1001的網路問卷。統計結果顯示，臺灣民眾服役的軍種以及評估受軍事訓練的有用程度，都對自我防衛決心有顯著影響（軍種主要為空軍較高），但與長官相處經驗則沒有影響。另一方面，越年長的世代，越傾向於覺得當年從軍所受的訓練有助於軍事防衛。本文也將在最後提出國家安全相關的政策建議。

關鍵字

安全研究 ； 義務役 ； 軍民關係 ； 從軍經驗 ； 自我防衛決心

並列摘要

What explains Taiwanese citizens' determination of self-defense? To date, few studies touch upon this issue. We argue that one's military service experience is an important factor for studying citizens' willingness to fight and hypothesize that positive experience could be conducive to higher willingness for self-defense as the citizens feel they have the capabilities and preparations for a conflict. We operationalize military service into three dimensions: military branch, evaluation of usefulness of military trainings, and interactions with units' senior officers. Using an original online survey conducted by National Chengchi University in July 2018, we find: (1) military branch matters-serving in the Air Force leads to higher determination, and (2) positive evaluations of the military training lead to higher determination. Additionally, we also find that the older generations believe that military trainings are effective for real conflicts. Based on the empirical findings, we propose several policy suggestions.

並列關鍵字

Security Studies ； determination for self-defense ； civil-military relations ； military experience ； mandatory military service

參考文獻

王宏恩，2017，〈台灣民眾遇到戰爭時會支持作戰嗎？民調結果十分分歧〉，https://whogovernstw.org/2017/11/02/austinwang29/，查閱時間：2020/12/01。Wang, Horng-En. 2017. “Tai wan min zhong yu dao zhan zheng shi hui zhi chi zuo zhan ma? min diao jie guo shi fen fen qi” [Will Taiwanese People Support Fighting when War Comes? Survey Results are Complicated]. (Accessed on December 1, 2020).

李幸鎧，2019，〈知覺風險、工作滿意度、轉換型領導、組織認同與國軍人留營意願關係之研究〉，《聯大學報》，16（2）：143-157。Li, Xing-yu. 2019. “Zhi jiao feng xian, gong zuo man yi du, zhuan huan xing ling dao, zu zhi ren tong yu guo jun ren liu ying yi yuan guan xi zhi yan jiu” [Research on the Relationship between Perceived Risk, Job Satisfaction, Transformational Leadership, Organizational Identity and Willingness of National Army to Stay in Office]. Journal of National United University, 16 (2): 143-157.

林育丞，2017，〈國軍與國民對共軍空降部隊威脅之認知：問卷調查研究〉，嘉義：南華大學國際事務與企業學系歐洲研究碩士論文。Lin, Yu-Cheng. 2017. Guo jun yu guo min dui gong jun kong jiang bu dui wei xie zhi ren zhi: wen juan diao cha yan jiu [The Cognition of the PLA and Nationals on the PLA Airborne Forces Threats: A Questionnaire Study]. Chiayi: MA Thesis, MA program of European Studies, Department of International Affairs and Business, Nanhua University.

林澤助，2010，〈影響國軍推動「募兵制」關鍵因素探討〉，《國防雜誌》，25（2）：102-122。Lin, Tse-chu. 2010. “Ying xiang guo jun tui dong ‘mu bing zhi’ guan jian yin su tan tao” [Critical Factors Affecting the Armed Forces’ Implementing All-Volunteer System]. National Defense Journal, 25 (2): 102-122.

俞振華，2013，〈網路民意調查的理論與實務〉，陳陸輝主編，《民意調查新論》：89-110，台北：五南書局。Yu, Chen-hua. 2013. “Wang lu min yi diao cha de li lun yu shi wu” [Theories and Practices of Internet Surveys]. In Chen, Lu-Huei ed, “Minyidiaocha Sin Lun” [The theory of public opinion survey revisited], pp. 89-110. Taipei: Wunan.