18世紀經由琉球途徑的清日文化交流

The Qing-Japan Cultural Exchange by Ryukyu's Intermediary Route during the 18th Century

沈玉慧(Yu-hui Shen)

《人文及社會科學集刊》 33卷1期 (2021/03) Pp. 81-111

摘要

1609年遭薩摩藩出兵的琉球，為了追求本國的自主性，及避免觸發清日間可能的體制衝突，自明清交替以來逐漸採取嚴格的隱蔽政策。中介於中日之間的琉球，為了因應薩摩藩與江戶幕府的需求，不僅居中傳遞情報、商品、文物、技術等，甚至中介雙方的文化交流活動。不同於情報、物品的傳遞，文化交流更仰賴人際網絡，因而亦見清朝官員也參與其中，成為中琉日往來途徑的重要元素。本文藉由17世紀以來此一途徑的發展，考察琉球透過土通事、冊封使節等官員所進行的清日文化交流事例，進而分析清朝官員於其中扮演的角色，探討中琉日交流網絡的形成、內涵及其意義。

關鍵字

近世琉球 ； 中介交流 ； 土通事 ； 冊封使節 ； 交流網絡

並列摘要

With the experience of being invaded by the Satsuma Domain in 1609, Ryukyu started to take a strict concealment policy during the Ming-Qing transition. Standing between Qing China and Japan, Ryukyu helped to transmit intelligence, commodities, antiquities, and technologies, among others, to meet the demands of Satsuma and the Shogunate at Edo, and even coordinated cultural exchange activities between Qing China and Japan. Different from the transmission of intelligence and objects, cultural exchange heavily depends on social networks. Indeed, involvement of some Han Chinese interpreters and officials working for the Qing government has been found in these activities. This paper investigates the development and transformation of Ryukyu's intermediary role, examines the cultural exchange activities between Qing China and Japan that involved Chinese participation and Ryukyu's coordination, analyzes the roles of interpreters and officials, and finally discusses the formation and significance of the exchange network between China, Ryukyu, Satsuma and Japan.

並列關鍵字

early modern Ryukyu ； intermediary exchange ； Han Chinese interpreters ； Qing investiture envoys ； exchange network

參考文獻

B.外文部分上原兼善 1981 　〈明末清初の動乱と琉球〉，見上原兼善，《鎖国と藩貿易：薩摩藩の琉球密貿易》，頁67–72。東京：八重岳書房。(Uehara, Kenzen, 1981, “The Disturbance in the Late Ming and Early Qing and Ryukyu,” pp. 67–72 in Kenzen Uehara, Sakoku and Trade by Han: Satsuma Han with Ryukyu Smuggling. Tokyo: Yaedake Shobou.)

大庭脩（編著） 1967 　《江戸時代における唐船持渡書の研究》。大阪：關西大學東西學術研究所。(Oba, Osamu (ed.), 1967, Studies in Chinese Books Imported in Japan in the Edo Period. Osaka: Institute of Oriental and Occidental Studies, Kansai University.)

山下廣幸 2003 　〈木村探元自画像の模写作品について〉，《黎明館調査研究報告》16: 1-10。(Yamashita, Hiroyuki, 2003, “The Reproduction of Kimura Tangen’s Self-Portrait,” Bulletin of Reimeikan, Kagoshima Prefectural Museum of Culture 16: 1–10.)

井上良吉年份不明　《薩藩画人伝》，鹿兒島縣立圖書館藏抄本。(Inoue, Ryokichi, n.d., Satsuhan Gazinden, Held at Kagoshima Prefectural Library.)

井上良吉（編） 1915 　《薩藩画人伝備考》。出版者不明。(Inoue, Ryokichi (ed.), 1915, Satsuhan Gazinden Bikou. Unknown Publisher.)