威權統治下的學術五毛與知識生產－一份轉型正義與知識不正義之間的跨領域研究倡議

Academic Charlatans and their Knowledge Production under Authoritarian Regime - An Interdisciplinary Research Proposal between Transitional Justice and Epistemic Injustice

杜坤峰(Kun-Feng Tu)

《東吳政治學報》 42卷1期 (2024/06) Pp. 205-270

摘要

本文藉由轉型正義與知識不正義的理論分析學術研究者與威權政權之間的關係，去解釋威權主義如何影響一個社會的知識生產與發展。透過案例研究，本文主張雖然兩方理論能部份地解釋一個威權統治下的社會在知識生產與傳播上所面臨的困難，但是它們各自的解釋似乎都無法充分地處理這個問題。在文獻回顧之後，本文發現：（1）轉型正義似乎無法解釋威權政權在知識上對一個社會所造成的負面影響，以及（2）知識不正義似乎無法解釋基於該政權之政治意識形態而來的偏見問題。據此，筆者提出一個跨領域研究計畫、其相關問題以及解答，以求更完整地理解這個問題，對轉型正義與知識不正義等理論做出學術貢獻。

關鍵字

二二八事件 ； 中山獎學金 ； 臺灣 ； 知識不正義 ； 轉型正義

並列摘要

This paper analyses the relationship between academic researchers and an authoritarian regime through theories of transitional justice and epistemic injustice to explicate how authoritarianism impacts knowledge production and development of a society. By case studies, the paper claims that although both theories could partially explain difficulties of production and spread of knowledge in an authoritarian-ruled society, it seems that each of their explanations taken individually is not adequate to address the problem. After reviewing the literatures, the paper finds that (1) transitional justice seems not able to explain the negative influences on knowledge on which an authoritarian regime has put the society and that (2) epistemic injustice seems not able to account for prejudices based on the political ideology of the regime. The author thereby proposes an interdisciplinary research project between the two fields so as not merely to seek a rather full understanding of the problem but to make contributions to them.

並列關鍵字

February 28 incident ； Sun Yat-sen scholarship ； Taiwan ； epistemic injustice ； transitional justice

參考文獻

王柏森 P.-S., P.-S.(2019).政黨政治甄補－以中國國民黨中山獎學金為例.國立政治大學=National Chengchi University.

王信賢,鄧巧琳 C.-L., C.-L.(2020).壟斷性侍從主義：中國國家社科基金項目中的國家社會關係.中國大陸研究.63(3),1-45.

公視新聞網=Punlic Television Service(2012).自由主義巨擘殷海光全集.

不當黨產處理委員會（2020a）。國民黨第八屆第二二一次中常會：聽取救總等單位在內之心戰工作報告、中山獎學金選拔經過與錄取名單通過革實院、省政府人事案（1960.6.8），1 月 15 日。https://www.cipas.gov.tw/stories/256 [Ill-gotten Party Assets Settlement Committee (2020a). Guomindang di ba jie di er er yi ci Zhongchanghui: Tingqu Jiuzong deng danwei zai nai zhi xinzhan gongzuo baogao, Zhongshan jiangxuejin xuanba jingguo yu luqu mingdan tongguo Geshiyuan, Shengzhengfu renshi an (1960.6.8), January 15.]

不當黨產處理委員會（2020b）。國民黨中山獎學金應考資格刪除黨齡五年一項 「因選擇條件所列各項均着重於從事黨務工作之實際成績徒具黨齡五年而對黨毫無貢獻者不應列爲選擇條件 」（1963.6.15），1 月 10 日。https://www.cipas.gov.tw/stories/252 [Ill-gotten Party Assets Settlement Committee (2020b). Guomindang Zhongshan jiangxuejin yingkao zige shanchu dangling wu nian yi xiang "Yin xuanze tiaojian suo lie ge xiang jun zhuozhong yu congshi dangwu gongzuo zhi shiji chengji tu ju dangling wu nian er dui dang haowu gongxian zhe bu ying lie wei xuanze tiaojian"(1963.6.15), January 10.]