清代中期與末期朝鮮的文化認同：歷史案例研究

Korea's Culture Identity in Mid and Late Qing Dynasty: A Historical Case Study

楊仕樂(Shih-Yueh Yang)

《政治學報》 Issue 73 (2022/06) Pp. 33-72

https://doi.org/10.6229/CPSR.202206_(73).0002

Abstracts

區域國家如何應對中國霸權？除了典型的現實主義權力政治觀點，建構主義式的文化認同觀點認為，區域國家是否認同中國文化，是關鍵的因素。明朝時，朝鮮對明朝是從反抗到順從甚至拼死效忠，其對明朝的中國文化認同，是在雙方長期互動累積的氣氛醞釀之下，再經明朝兩度大軍協防抵禦日本入侵之後，才驟然產生的。不過，朝鮮對明朝的效忠就是對後續清朝的抵抗，清初時朝鮮迫於威逼而得服從清朝，但到了清朝末年朝鮮內部卻也有持續效忠清朝的呼聲。朝鮮到了清末，對清朝是否也有文化認同？若有，其形成的過程是否與明朝時相同？本文發現，經清代中期至末期，朝鮮仍然認同明朝所代表的中國文化正統。明代所建立起的文化認同呈現驚人的持續力，歷經近三百年之後仍然存在。

Keywords

文化認同 ； 中國崛起 ； 明朝 ； 清朝 ； 朝鮮

Parallel abstracts

How do regional states respond to Chinese hegemony? In addition to the typical realist view of power politics, the constructivist view of cultural identity holds that whether regional states accept and admire Chinese culture is the key factor. While Korea was strongly against the Ming Dynasty in early days, it became loyal to the Ming until the very end of the Ming Dynasty, Korea's Chinese cultural identity to the Ming was brewed in an atmosphere of long-term interaction between the two sides and then show up suddenly after Ming's protection of Korea against the Japanese aggression. Korea'ss allegiance to the Ming was exactly the resistance to the follow-up Qing. In the early Qing, Korea was forced to submit, but in the late Qing period, there were calls for continued allegiance to the Qing. Did Korea also develop a cultural identity with the Qing by late Qing period? If so, was the process the same as in the Ming? This article finds that, form mid to late Qing, Korea still adhered to the legitimate Chinese culture represented by Ming. This cultural identity established during the Ming showed an astonishing persistence, which existed for almost three centuries.

Parallel keywords

Culture Identity ； Rise of China ； Ming Dynasty ； Qing Dynasty ； Korea

References

吳慶第(2011).韓國近代化改革運動之研究—以甲申政變為例.嶺東學報.29,199-212.

楊仕樂(2018).崛起中國的權力政治或文化認同？歷史上中韓關係的實證檢驗1368 ~ 1449.遠景基金會季刊.19(1),109-156.

林亨芬(2011).甲午戰後清朝對朝鮮政策研究—以1896年遣使議約為例.史耘.15,45-63.

楊仕樂(2019).漸變乎？驟變乎？明代中期以後朝鮮對中文化認同的歷史案例研究.政治學報.68,39-73.

朴炳培(2019).十九世紀末朝鮮的中國認識之背景與「脫中」問題.政治科學論叢.82,39-80.