透過您的圖書館登入
IP:18.119.1.164
  • 期刊

論占有連鎖-建議民法債編增訂有償利用基地建屋之規定

A Chain of Possession

摘要


本文首先整理分析占有連鎖之法理與適用要件,其次說明我國立法者就占有連鎖之中間人是否具有將其直接占有移轉與占有人之權限一事,分別於民法物權編與民法債編各論設有不同之價值決定。在前者場合,率賦予典權人、地上權人、以及農育權人具有將其直接占有移轉與占有人之權能。與此相對的,於後者情形,是否給予斯項權限殆委諸於私法自治。惟於當事人對此並無特別表示時,立法者基本上傾向於保護出租人、貸與人等這些交付標的物予相對人使用之當事人的信任關係而採取否定態度,俾合理控制因第三人使用該物致增加毀損滅失或貶值之風險。最後,本文建議我國民法債編第426-1條增訂第2項關於「有償利用基地建築房屋,房屋移轉於受讓人時,其有償利用基地契約,對於房屋受讓人,亦繼續存在。」之規定,以解決實務上透過占有連鎖法理所欲解決之拆屋還地問題。

並列摘要


The purpose of this article, which is divided into three parts, is to analyze the existing fundament and conditions of application for a Chain of Possessions/a Multi-Class Possession in Taiwan. Following an introduction relative to problematic in theory and practice, Part II explores and interprets the jurisprudence of Taiwan Supreme Court. This study reveals that the real rights law entitles in principle a dian-holder, a superficiary, or an agricultural right holder to transfer legally his direct possession to another person. On the contrary, we discover that in the field of obligation law, unless otherwise agreed by the parties, a lessee or a borrower of land is not entitled to transfer legally his possession to another person. This nuance is justified by the different nature and character between Rights In Rem and contract law. Finally, Part III concludes by offering an additional article proposition of Article 426-1 to Taiwan Civil Code.

參考文獻


王澤鑑,基於債之關係占有權的相對性及物權化,收錄於氏著「民法學說與判例研究第七冊」,自版,1992 年9 月,頁74-96。
司法院公報第53 卷第2 期,2011 年2 月。
吳瑾瑜,所有權行使與權利濫用-以土地受讓人受讓前知悉房屋存在嗣後訴請拆屋還地的問題為例,台北大學法學論叢第78 期,2011 年6 月,頁43-110。
姚志明,占有連鎖與不當得利-評最高法院104 年度台上字第40 號民事判決,月旦裁判時報第47 期,2016 年5 月,頁12-19。
游進發,占有連鎖的存在與本質-在任意規定與當事人意思,月旦法學雜誌第231 期,2014 年8 月,頁206-219。

延伸閱讀