Emerson's Indian Awakening and Religious Dissent: Thomas Moore's ＂Veiled Prophet of Khorassan＂ in Emerson's Early Writing and the Divinity School Address

Justin M. Hewitson

《文山評論：文學與文化》 13卷2期 (2020/06) Pp. 121-151

https://doi.org/10.30395/WSR.202006_13(2).0006

摘要

Emerson's polemical 1838 Harvard Divinity School Address urged clergyman to break from Christianity's doctrinal errors-specifically Unitarian dependence on miracles and its ＂noxious＂ representation of Jesus. He believed Indian monism could help restore etiolated Christianity to its former status as a pure ＂doctrine of the soul＂ (Emerson and Atkinson 68). Emerson's mature studies of India's spiritual works are widely acknowledged to have influenced his approach to self-realization and concepts of monism. Researchers have also noted his youthful enjoyment and subsequent disdain of Romantic Orientalism; however, the links between Lalla Rookh, the Oriental fantasy by Sir Thomas Moore, the Irish Romanticist, and Emerson's early religious dissent remain unexplored. Emerson was a fourteen-year-old Harvard freshman in 1817 when he read extensive reviews of the popular work published in the same year. He references Rookh at significant junctures in his journals and discourses. This paper explores the connections between Rookh's first frame narrative, ＂The Veiled Prophet of Khorassan＂ (VP), which offered an early critique of religious myopia, and Emerson's opposition to Unitarian doctrine. I examine the historiography of the New Englander's initial intellectual engagement with Indian spirituality through VP. Thereafter, I briefly analyze the intersection of VP's religious themes with Emerson's inaugural essays, Nature and ＂The American Scholar.＂ My conclusion details the intriguing conceptual and oratorical parallels between Mokanna's critique of religious dogma and Emerson's dissent in the Divinity Address. By arguing that Christians would do well to understand Indian monism, Emerson set the stage for critical spirituality in American Transcendentalism.

關鍵字

Thomas Moore ； Emerson ； Divinity School Address ； Lalla Rookh ； India ； religious dissent ； monism ； Orientalism ； Romanticism ； American Transcendentalism

參考文獻

Adisasmito-Smith, Steven. “Transcendental Brahmin: Emerson’s ‘Hindu’ Sentiments.” Emerson for the Twenty-First Century: Global Perspectives on an American Icon, edited by Barry Tharaud, U of Delaware P, 2013.

Ánandamúrti, Shrii Shrii. Discourses on Tantra: Volume 2. Ananda Marga Publications, 1994.

Ánandamúrti, Shrii Shrii. Yoga Sādhanā. Ananda Marga Publications, 2010.

Bussey, Marcus. “Critical Spirituality: Towards a Revitalized Humanity.” Journal of Futures Studies, vol. 10, no. 4, 2006, pp. 39-44.

Cameron, Kenneth Walter. Indian Superstition by Ralph Waldo Emerson Edited with a Dissertation on Emerson’s Orientalism at Harvard. Friends of the Dartmouth Library, 1954.