屬靈分辨中關於聖靈引導之「可辨性」的爭議與疏解－一項根據布克比父子、弗利森、史密思之對話的研究

The "Discernibility" of the Guidance of the Holy Spirit in Spiritual Discernment: A Study on the Controversies among Blackabys, G. Friesen, and Gordon T. Smith

抑扉(Fei Yi)

《建道學刊》 61期 (2024/01) Pp. 99-135

摘要

本文透過分析當代福音派關於分辨上主引導的三種代表性理論－布克比父子的「特定旨意說」、弗利森的「智慧說」與史密思的「關係說」－之間的對話與爭議，意在探究他們在聖靈引導之「可辨性」這項核心議題上存在的嚴重分歧和理論缺陷，藉此指出，探索由聖靈引導而產生的「感知經驗」是重新建構福音派屬靈分辨實踐的一種有效途徑。

並列摘要

Henry & Richard Blackaby, Garry Friesen, Gordon T. Smith are respectively the representatives of "specific-will view," "wisdom view" and "relationship view," which are the three different views on discerning God's guidance in contemporary evangelical Christian. This paper investigates their deep disagreements and flaws of practical theory on the discernibility of guidance of Holy Spirit by analyzing the dialogues and controversies among them. This study suggests that exploring the experience of perception that results from the guidance of the Holy Spirit is a feasible direction to reconstruct the practice of evangelical spiritual discernment.