春秋戰國時期為君父復讎所涉之忠孝議題及相關經義探究

Exploring Loyalty and Filial Piety in Regard to Revenge for the Monarch and Father during the Spring & Autumn and Warring States Periods

林素娟(Su-Chuan Lin)

《漢學研究》 24卷1期 (2006/06) Pp. 35-70

摘要

春秋戰國時期復讎風氣頗為盛行，所涉層面很廣，倫理的報與交換、公與私的衝突、對死靈的慰藉、君臣的關係、忠孝的矛盾與取捨等，均為其重要議題。本文由復讎在君臣、父子關係問所彰顯的忠孝觀及倫理矛盾著眼，章節內容安排如下：
一、從《春秋》經傳有關弒君書法所衍生的爭議著手，並對三傳引起重大爭議的稱國、稱某國人弒君以懲君惡之說進行深入探討。二、說明懲戒惡君之說，符合於春秋戰國時期特殊的政治環境及當時士人對君臣關係的思考。三、由禮書、出土文獻探討先秦儒家倫理觀中忠與孝、公與私、父與君孰輕孰重，以及面臨忠孝、公私衝突時，當事者該如何取捨等問題。四、於具體復讎事例中，觀察實際面臨忠孝衝突時，當事人之矛盾與擇取，及難以避免的悲劇性。

關鍵字

忠孝 ； 君臣 ； 復讎 ； 春秋戰國 ； 公與私

並列摘要

The phenomena of revenge thrived during the Spring & Autumn period, and involved numerous related problems. For example, bao報 and exchange of ethics, conflict between public and private, consolation to the spirit of the dead, the relationship between the monarch and courtiers, and contradictions between loyalty and filial piety.
This paper will discuss these issues from several aspects:
1. Comments by historical figures regarding the assassination of monarchs in the Chunqiu春秋 (Spring & Autumn Annals), and the three commentaries on the Chunqiu春秋三傅.
2. Expositions of punishments to the tyrant during the Spring & Autumn and Warring States periods.
3. Discussion about the selection between loyalty/filial piety, and monarch/father in the pre-Qin era.
4. Observation of the contradiction and tragedy which encountered the conflict of loyalty and filial piety in actual cases of revenge during the Spring & Autumn and Warring States periods.

並列關鍵字

loyalty/filial piety ； monarch/courtier ； revenge ； Chunqiu春秋 ； public/private

參考文獻

吳韋昭(1998)。國語。

宋邢昺(2001)。論語注疏。

宋孫奭(2001)。孟子注疏。

唐孔穎達(2001)。春秋左傳正義。

唐孔穎達(2001)。禮記注疏。