臺南原日軍步兵第二聯隊官舍兒玉源太郎頭像材質再考

Re-examination of the Material of the Bust of Kodama Gentaro from the Former Japanese Army Second Infantry Regiment Officer's Dormitories in Tainan

林秋婷(Chiou-ting Lin) ； 陳衫瑩(Shan-Ying Chen)

《國立臺灣博物館學刊》 77卷3期 (2024/09) Pp. 71-75

https://doi.org/10.6532/JNTM.202409_77(3).04

摘要

邵慶旺、盧泰康（2023）提倡從科學分析及藝術史學跨領域的視角合作進行古物的研究，試圖提供多元的證據協助研究者對兒玉源太郎頭像殘件有更深入了解值得被肯定。然而，作者對於頭像材質檢測數據的錯誤解釋，並於結論指出兒玉源太郎頭像材質並非史料所云為「大理石」，可能造成後續讀者對該古物及史料有錯誤理解。

關鍵字

兒玉源太郎 ； 大理石 ； 臺南市 ； 原日軍步兵第二聯隊官舍 ； 拉曼光譜儀

並列摘要

Cing-wang Shao and Tai-kang Lu (2023) advocated for an interdisciplinary approach combining scientific analysis and art history to conduct research on antiquities. They aimed to provide diverse evidence to help researchers gain a deeper understanding of the bust of Kodama Gentaro, which is commendable. However, their erroneous interpretation of the geochemical data, concluding that the bust is not "marble," could lead to subsequent misunderstandings of the antiquity and related historical materials.

並列關鍵字

Kodama Gentaro ； Marble ； Tainan City ； Former Japanese Army Second Infantry Regiment Officer's Dormitories ； Raman Spectroscopy

參考文獻

邵慶旺、盧泰康，2023。從物件的詮釋「文物」之研究：以兒玉源太郎頭像殘件研究為 例，國立臺灣博物館學刊，76 (2): 58-98。

Gauri, K. L., Chowdhury, A. N., Kulshreshtha, N. P. & Punuru, A. R. 1989. The sulfation of marble and the treatment of gypsum crusts. Studies in Conservation 34 (4): 201-206.

Giustetto, R., Pastero, L. & Aquilano, D., 2020. Potential effects of the shape of gypsum aggregates on the early sulfation of marble and travertine, Journal of Building Engineering 32: 101794.

Zhang, J., Andrew, J., Birnbaum, Y., Yao, L., Xu, F. & Lombardi, J. R. 2007. Effect of fluence on the discoloration of marble cleaned with UV lasers, Applied Surface Science 253 (6): p.3083-3092.