中共建政初期的防疫經驗與疾病治理：「治療型國家」的觀點

Epidemic Prevention Experience and Health Governance in Early Years of the People's Republic of China: A ＂Therapeutic State＂ Perspective

蔡儀儂(Yi-nung Tsai)

《中國大陸研究》 65卷1期 (2022/03) Pp. 71-101

https://doi.org/10.30389/MCS.202203_65(1).0003

摘要

關於1949年後中國早期防疫經驗，部分研究察覺防疫治理的動員特徵，與醫療實作的科學主義；但國家如何藉由防疫經驗，建構早期防疫體制與政權特性，則少有討論。為了補充既有文獻的空白，本文使用醫療史的治療型國家（therapeutic state）理論，解釋中國1949∼1957年的防疫經驗。首先，由於民國時期雜揉式的公衛體制，與公衛資源短缺等問題，使中共建政以戰時防疫經驗為基礎建立防疫體制。其次，這種制度遺緒，使中共建立一套雙軌制度的防疫監控機制，防疫站即為這種制度下的例證。第三，這套防疫監控機制，受限於黨政體系冗長的議價過程，及職能疊床架屋的問題，使專業性的疫情監督系統，受到資源排擠與政治干預。整體而論，這對理解當代中國防疫體制的延續性特徵，尤其是近期中國的傳染病疫情的資源錯置與疾病監管難題，仍具意義。

關鍵字

治療型國家 ； 疾病治理 ； 中國 ； 公共衛生

並列摘要

Some studies on the early-stage epidemic prevention efforts in post-1949 China have observed the characteristic of mobilization in epidemic governance and scientism in healthcare practices. However, little research has explored how the state drew on its epidemic prevention experience to develop an epidemic prevention system and regime nature in the early years. To fill this gap in the literature, this study expounds on China's experience in epidemic prevention from 1949 to 1957 using the therapeutic state theory of the history of medicine. First, in view of hybrid public health institutions implemented during the Republican era and a shortage of public health resources, among other problems, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) established an epidemic prevention system based on its experience in wartime epidemic prevention. Second, this study contends that such institutional legacies led the CCP to establish a double-track system combining epidemic prevention and surveillance mechanisms. Third, this epidemic prevention-surveillance system was confined by the prolonged bargaining process of the party-government system and the problem of overlapping functions, which in turn subjected the professional epidemic monitoring system to resource crowding out and political interference. In general, this holds some significance for understanding the continuity of China's epidemic prevention systems in contemporary times, particularly in regard to misallocation of resources and difficulties with disease monitoring and control confronting China during recent infectious disease outbreaks.

並列關鍵字

Therapeutic state ； Epidemic governance ； China ； Public Health

參考文獻

上海衛生志編纂委員會編，1998，《上海衛生志》，上海：上海社會科學出版社。Compilation Committee of the Gazetteer of Public Health in Shanghai. ed. 1998. Shanghai weisheng zhi [Gazetteer of Public Health in Shanghai]. Shanghai: Shanghai Academy of Social Science Press.

山東省地方史志編纂委員會編，1995，《山東省志．衛生志》，濟南：山東人民出版社。Shandong Provincial Local Chronicles Compilation Committee. ed.1995. Shandongsheng zhi．weisheng zhi [Gazetteer of Shandong Province: Public Health]. Jinan: Shandong People’ Press.

中央人民政府衛生部編，1950，《全國衛生情況參考資料》，北京：中央人民政府衛生部。Ministry of Health of the Central People’s Government. ed. 1950. Quanguo weisheng qingkuang cankao ziliao [Nationwide Health Situation Reference Material]. Beijing: Ministry of Health of the Central People’s Government.

中央研究院近代史研究所，2014，《近代婦女期刊資料庫》，https://mhdb.mh.sinica.edu.tw/ACWP/author.php?no=1374，查閱時間：2020/09/20。Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica. 2014. Jindai funü qikan ziliaoku [Authorship of Chinese Women’s Periodicals]. (Accessed on September 20, 2020).

中共中央文獻研究室編，1993，《毛澤東文集（六）》，北京：中央文獻出版社。Central Chinese Communist Party Literature Research Office. ed. 1993. Mao Zedong wenji (lu) [Mao Zedong@@$$s Collected Works, vol. 6]. Beijing: Central Party Literature Press.