論「詩人之詩」與「學人之詩」

Criticising "Poems by Poets" and "Poems by Scholars"

陳秀香(Hsiu-Hsiang Chen)

《國文天地》 295期 (2009/12) Pp. 113-124

摘要

本文主要從近年來「詩人之詩」與「學人之詩」中，存在的一些傾向所引發的思考。嘗試以「詩人之詩」與「學人之詩」為主軸，重新加以檢視，追溯其源頭，釐清其演變。諸如對「詩人之詩」、「學人之詩」與唐宋詩之爭，以及「學人之詩」與「文人之詩」、「儒者之詩」等關係，進行論析，從而對「詩人之詩」與「學人之詩」的特徵，作出說明，提出其核心內容，並由之而指出其對清代的詩歌創作和詩學批評的借鑒意義。

關鍵字

詩人之詩 ； 學人之詩 ； 唐宋詩之爭 ； 清詩

並列摘要

The inspiration of this paper is stimulated by recent discussions concerning ”poems by poets” and ”poems by scholars”. It aims at tracing the origin of ”poems by poets” and ”poems by scholars”, as well as clarifying their evolutions (for example, the examination on ”poems by poets” and ”poems by scholars”, the dispute between Tang poetry and Song poetry, as well as the analysis over the evolution of scholarly poems throughout the history). These thoughts lead to the identification of the characteristics of ”poems by poets” and ”poems by scholars”, as well as the influence they have on the poetic creation and the criticism on the poetry in the Qing Dynasty.

並列關鍵字

poems by poets ； poems by scholars ； Qing poetry ； the dispute between Tang poetry and Song poetry