從殺夫小說〈女陪審團〉與《殺夫》－探勘手刃親夫的隱喻世界

Discovering the Metaphysical World of "Killing-Husband" According to the Novel The Butcher's Wife and "A Jury of Her Peer"

唐毓麗(Yu-Li Tang)

《東海中文學報》 15期 (2003/07) Pp. 269-306

https://doi.org/10.29726/TJCL.200307.0010

摘要

本文運用喬治•萊科夫(Gorge Lakoff)和馬克•約翰生(Mark Johnson)著作Metaphors We Live by《我們賴以維生的隱喻》中「Metaphors」隱喻的三個範疇，重新延伸詮釋李昂(1952-)《殺夫》與美國作家蘇珊•葛雷斯珮爾(Susan Glaspell, 1882-1948)”A Jury of Her Peers”〈女陪審團〉兩篇女性殺夫小說，發現小說中不論是鹿城／陳宅或狄克生郡／萊特家的容器隱喻，都揭露了家庭原是男性暴力橫行的場域。小說中的方位隱喻挾帶著性能力、經濟力、權勢的昭示意圖，這是男性本體經驗主宰權力以及性別政治裡男性霸權文化的歷史基礎。女性殺夫小說除有尖銳的社會批判意義外，手刃親夫的驚駭行動，積極呈現女性對第二性處境的覺醒，但也消極地指明兩性衝突不得不以「殺人」方式終結的困局。在層層疊疊方位隱喻(orientational metaphor)、本體隱喻(ontological metaphor)與結構隱喻(structural metaphor)呼應與串連的架構下，一再直指父權體制下「婚姻是女人的災難」的警世隱喻。「女性小說」展現女性「身體、主體、文本」三位一體的書寫文本，探索「殺夫」小說的隱喻世界，正可作為一個簡要切入點，追索男性文化「宰制權力」的禍首根源，對「父權」、「男尊女卑」意識型態的解碼應具特殊的意義。

關鍵字

李昂 ； 蘇珊•葛雷斯珮爾 ； 殺夫 ； 女陪審團 ； 殺夫小說 ； 隱喻 ； 喬治•萊科夫 ； 馬克•約翰生

並列摘要

Using three metaphor scopes (orientational, ontological and structural) from Gorge Lakoff and Mark Johnson's Metaphors We Live By, this article examines Li Ang's The Butcher's Wife（李昂，《殺夫》） and American novelist Susan Glaspell's ”A Jury of Here Peers,” and draws a conclusion that home is a field where man's violence prevails. The orientational metaphor contains a man's sexual ability, economic ability and power, which form a historical basis of male hegemony that has come to dominate in power and gender politics. The fictional work with killing-husband theme not only criticizes society acutely, but also awakens female readers through a presentation of the heroine's shocking behavior of killing husband. However, the theme of ”killing-husband” also implies the invalidity of ending family conflicts by ”killing.” By using orientational, ontological and structural metaphors, this article focuses on the metaphor ”marriage is female's disaster under the patriarchy system.” Novels by female writers show a context of combining ”body, ontology and text.” This paper uses the metaphorical world of killing husband as a point of departure and goes on to discusses the source of Chinese and Western male culture of ”dominating power.” This line of investigation will be significant for the analysis and deconstruction of the ideology of ”patriarchy” and ”man dominating woman.”

並列關鍵字

Li Ang ； Susan Glaspell ； The Butcher's Wife ； "A Jury of Her Peers" ； killing-husband novel ； Gorge Lakoff ； Mark Johnson

參考文獻

李昂(1983)。殺夫。台北:聯經出版公司。

蘇珊·葛雷斯珮爾、Glaspell, Susan、楊瑛美譯(1999)。難解之緣。台北:聯經出版社。

克勞芙、P Clough、Patricia Ticineto、夏傳位譯(1997)。女性主義思想：慾望、權力及學術論述。台北:巨流圖書公司。

蕭瓦特,E Showalter,Elaine,Mary Eagleton (ed.)(1994).Feminist Literary Theory: A Reader.Cambridge MA, Oxford UK:Blackwell.

蕭瓦特、E Showalter、Elaine、張小虹譯(1986)。荒野中的女性社評=Feminist Criticism in the Wilderness。中外文學。14(10)，77-134。