論唐君毅疏解陽明與船山義理衝突

Synthesizes Wang Yangming and Wang Chuanshan by Tang Junyi philosophy

李瑋皓(Lee-Wei Hao)

《東吳中文學報》 34期 (2017/11) Pp. 281-306

摘要

本文旨在試圖以唐君毅先生之義理為基礎，提出疏解王陽明與王船山義理衝突之可能。誠然此處之「疏解」，並不是以一家義理強行比附另外一家之義理，而是分別以兩者獨特義理中之旨趣，見其同中有異，異中有同之處。是以本文之開展，即從「陽明與船山義理中『天道』之義蘊」；接著論述「陽明與船山義理中『心性與物』之義蘊」；最後闡述「陽明與船山義理中『工夫』之義蘊」。以下即依上述架構，逐步展開疏解之討論。

關鍵字

唐君毅 ； 王陽明 ； 王船山 ； 疏解

並列摘要

This article is for the purpose of attempting round to melt the philosophy take Tang Junyi as a foundation, proposes Wang Yangming and Wang Chuanshan possibility of the philosophy. Indeed here it ＂the synthesis＂, is not appends forcefully by a philosophy other philosophy, but is respectively by both unique philosophy in the idea of, sees it to have differently with, different has with it place. Is development by this article, namely from ＂Yangming and Chuanshan philosophy 'implication of the sun'＂; Then elaborates ＂Yangming and in the Chuanshan philosophy implication of the 'disposition and the thing'＂; Finally elaborates ＂Yangming and in the Chuanshan philosophy 'implication of the training'＂. The following namely according to the above construction, launches discussion gradually the synthesis.

並列關鍵字

Tang Junyi ； Wang Yangming ； Wang Chuanshan ； Synthesizes

參考文獻

明王守仁、吳光編校、錢明編校、董平編校、姚延福編校(2014)。王陽明全集。上海:上海古籍出版社。

明黃宗羲、清王夫之(2015)。黃梨州王船山書。臺北:世界書局。

清王夫之(2011)。張子正蒙注。北京:中華書局。

清王夫之、李一忻點校(2010)。周易內傳。北京:九州出版社。

清王夫之、李一忻點校(2010)。周易外傳。北京:九州出版社。