台灣銀行產業結構及經營效率與會計獲利能力指標之關聯性研究

Relationship between Accounting Profitability, Market Structure and Efficiency in Taiwan Banking Industry

劉啟群(Chi-Chun Liu) ； 楊慧敏(Hu-Ming Yang)

《Asia Pacific Management Review》 4卷2期 (1999/06) Pp. 109-129

https://doi.org/10.6126/APMR.1999.4.2.02

摘要

銀行獲利能力之根源係歸因於整體銀行產業集中度、個別銀行市場力量或個別銀行之管理效率及規模經濟效率，一直為經濟及管理學界重視之議題。本文依據文獻、參考國內金融環境之變化及公民營型態之差異，收集民國70年至83年上市、上櫃及公開發行共34家商業銀行之相關資料，觀察金融產業結構及經營效率與獲利能力是否具關聯性。實證結果顯示，整體而言，如從全體銀行觀之，銀行之獲利能力不僅來自銀行市場力量且與銀行管理效率有重大關聯。但如以民營銀行而論，相對市場力量才是區分民營銀行獲利能力之最主要因素；相對地，公營銀行間獲利能力之差異，主要係源自各銀行之管理效率，而非市場力量。以ROA為獲利能力指標之實證結果：（1）所有銀行：結構－行為－績效假說成立，市場佔有率與ROA為負向關係、且達顯著水準，與預期不相符。（2）公營銀行：結構－行為－績效假說、規模經濟效率結構假說成立，管理效率亦有相當影響力。（3）民營銀行：結構－行為－績效假說相對市場力量假說、管理效率結構假說成立。以ROE為獲利能力指標之實證結果：（1）所有銀行：結構－行為－績效假說成立、相對市場力量假說、規模經濟效率結構假說成立，管理效率亦有相當影響力。（2）公營銀行：管理效率結構假說、規模經濟效率結構假說成立。（3）民營銀行：結構－行為－績效假說、相對市場力量假說成立。

關鍵字

會計獲利能力 ； 產業結構 ； 經營效率

並列摘要

This study examines the relationship between accounting profitability, market structure, and efficiency in Taiwan banking industry. Specifically, market structure hypotheses (i.e., market share and industry concentration) and efficiency hypotheses (i.e., scale efficiency and management or production technologies) are tested. The purpose of this study is to employ tests that distinguish among these two theories. Although market structure hypotheses had been tested in prior studies, impromements in examing efficiency hypotheses of Taiwan banking industry, expecially, in how to measure eficiency, are still very much needed. In addition, different ownership types of banks are also investigated. The main results support our hypotheses that both market structure and efficiency are important determinants of bank profitability. The findings also indicate that the major source of profitability for state-owned banks comes from management efficiency, in contrast, market power is the main driving force behind the profitability of private banks.

並列關鍵字

Accounting Profitability ； Market Structure ； Efficiency

參考文獻

Berger, Allen N.(1993).Distribution-Free Estimates of Efficiency in the U. S. Banking Industry and Tests of the Standard Distributional Assumptions.Journal of Productivity Analysis.4

Berger, Allen N.(1995).The Profit-Structure Relationship in Banking - Tests of Market-Power and Efficient-Structure Hypotheses.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking.27

Demsetz, H.(1974).Industrial Concentration: The New Learning.Boston:Little Brown.

Demsetz, Harold(1973).Industry Structure, Market Rivalry, and Public Policy.Journal of Law and Economics.16

Evanoff, Douglas D., Fortier, Diane(1988).Reevaluation of the Structure-Conduct-Performance Relationship in Banking.Journal of Financial Services Research.1