The purpose of this research study was to examine the peer relationships of mathematically gifted junior high school male students. In order to gain a holistic picture of the peer-related issues encountered by three mathematically gifted junior high school male students, this study adopted a research design of qualitative multi-case study. The process of data collection took approximately one year, which included in-depth interviews with the three students and their mothers, document review, and observation of their learning activities. The themes uncovered were strong need for attention, heightened sensitivity during the interaction with others, the higher frequency of sharing words in mind with friends than with parents, denial of natural giftedness in most of their classmates, and influence of their attitude toward peer competition on their placement preference. These findings were discussed in the context of the existing literature, and implications for the education of the gifted male students were presented.