極端反應風格之多向度試題反應理論模式的發展與應用

Multidimensional Item Response Theory Models for Extreme Response Style

黃宏宇(Hung-Yu Huang) ； 孫慧芳(Huifang Sun)

《測驗學刊》 65卷4期 (2018/12) Pp. 401-438

摘要

在社會科學的調查研究中，極端反應風格的存在經常會造成測驗品質的威脅。本研究旨在發展一組新的試題反應理論（item response theory, IRT）模式，適用於多向度測驗分析，並同時能納入極端反應風格的隨機效果。研究者擴展四種適用多元計分的多向度試題反應理論（multidimensional IRT, MIRT）模式，並透過模擬研究操弄多種不同情境，使用貝氏估計法檢驗模式參數的回復性。研究結果顯示：本研究所發展出的四個新模式具有良好的估計品質。在試題參數估計方面，隨著向度增加、樣本數增加與向度之間呈現高相關時，能提供良好的試題參數估計；在潛在特質與權重參數估計方面，其樣本數、題數與向度增加時，受試者參數估計有不錯的效果。此外，向度間的高相關也能提升各向度特質之估計。實徵研究分析顯示：有納入極端反應風格的模式具有較佳的模式適配度，忽略極端反應風格時會造成潛在特值估計的偏誤。最後，研究者提出若干建議供未來研究發展參考。

關鍵字

多向度測驗 ； 貝氏估計 ； 極端反應風格 ； 試題反應理論

並列摘要

This study aims to develop a new set of multidimensional item response theory (MIRT) models for extreme response style (ERS). Four polytomous MIRT models were extended to incorporate the ERS effect in the item response functions. We conducted a series of simulations to assess the efficiency of the proposed models in terms of parameter recovery using Bayesian estimation. The results showed that a large sample size, a great number of dimensions, and high correlation between dimensions were associated with satisfactory item parameter recovery and that the latent trait and ERS weight parameters could be estimated precisely when the large sample size, the long test length and a great number of dimensions were used. In addition, as in multidimensional IRT models, the correlation between latent traits can provide precise latent trait estimation. An empirical example was provided to demonstrate the applications of the proposed model to real data analysis and the consequences of ignoring the ERS effect on persons' parameter estimation were investigated. We closed this article by addressing several suggestions for future study.

並列關鍵字

Bayesian estimation ； extreme response style ； item response theory ； multidimensional tests

參考文獻

陳柏熹(2006)。能力估計方法對多向度電腦化適性測驗測量精準度的影響。教育心理學報。38，93-210。

蔡芸()。,未出版。

Andrich, D.(1978).A rating formulation for ordered response categories.Psychometrika.43,561-573.

Batchelor, J. H.,Miao, C.,McDaniel, M. A.(2013).Extreme response style: A metaanalysis.Presented at the 28th annual conference of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology.(Presented at the 28th annual conference of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology).:

Baumgartner, H.,Steenkamp, J. E. M.(2001).Response styles in marketing research: A cross-national investigation.Journal of Marketing Research.38,143-156.