數理科學的學習動機有性別差異嗎？一個來自後設分析的證據

STUDENTS' LEARNING MOTIVATION TO MATH AND SCIENCE: USING THE META-ANALYSIS TO FIND THE GENDER DIFFERENCE IN TAIWAN

余民寧(Min-Ning Yu) ； 翁雅芸(Ya-Yun Weng) ； 張靜軒(Ching-Hsuan Chang)

《當代教育研究季刊》 26卷1期 (2018/03) Pp. 45-75

https://doi.org/10.6151/CERQ.201803_26(1).0002

摘要

研究目的：本研究統整臺灣1993年到2013年所發表的學位論文與期刊論文，透過後設分析法以釐清臺灣學生在數理科學的學習動機、學習興趣與學習態度等情意層面上，是否存在性別差異。研究設計／方法／取徑：本研究以「臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統」和「臺灣期刊論文索引系統」當作檢索工具，搜尋國內的期刊和博碩士論文，最後共採納72篇論文進行後設分析。研究發現或結論：整體來說，兩性在數理科學學習動機等因素具有顯著性別差異，呈現男學生優於女學生的現象。透過調節變項檢定發現，除樣本大小不會影響其性別差異以外，研究年代、地區、學習階段、數理科學科目、研究變項（學習動機／學習興趣／學習態度）以及變項組成因素等皆會對性別差異產生影響。雖然在國小階段性別差異未達顯著，但隨著年齡增長，性別差異逐漸擴大，到高中職階段則最為明顯；南部地區的性別差異最為顯著，中部地區的性別差異則未達統計顯著。2009年至2013年間，臺灣學生在數理科學學習動機等情意層面的性別差異較過去更為明顯，代表目前教育環境與社會環境對於女性學習數理科學或許仍不夠友善，或無法給予適切的支持。研究原創性／價值：本研究整合臺灣長達20年內所發表的學位論文與期刊論文，針對臺灣兩性學生在數理科學學習動機等因素方面提出整合後的研究結果，並反映臺灣學生在數理科學學習動機等因素上存在不同程度的性別差異，提供此重大警訊，供後續研究與教育輔導參考。

關鍵字

性別差異 ； 數理科學 ； 學習動機 ； 後設分析 ； 臺灣

並列摘要

Purpose: The meta-analysis method was used in analyzing data extracted from thesis and peer review journals from 2003 to 2013, as inputs in understanding male students or female students who have the better learning motivation, learning interest and learning attitude in math, nature science and computer science. Design/methodology/approach: This study extracted the articles of journals from ＂PerioPath Index to Taiwan Periodical Literature System＂ and the articles of theses and dissertations form ＂National Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations in Taiwan.＂ Totally, 72 journal and these articles were collected and used in this study. Findings: Meta-analysis results showed that the male students had a significant outperformance than female students. The published times, the stage of schooling, the subjects (math, science and computer science), the variables (motivation/attitude/interest), and the subscales all had a significant impact on the gender difference. But the variable impact of sample size was not significant. In the elementary school, the gender difference was not significant, but the gap of gender difference was increasing, especially in the stage of high schooling. The gender difference was highest in the south area cities of Taiwan, however in the midland area cities of Taiwan, the gender difference was not significant. The past five years, Taiwan's students had more gender difference in the learning motivation, learning interest, and learning attitude in math, nature science, and computer science. The results meant that the society was not friendly supported for female students in studying math and science. Originality/value: This study integrates the researches from dissertation and journal in Taiwan for past 20 years. The meta-analysis was used to examine the gender differences in the learning motivation, learning interest, and learning attitude in math, nature science, and computer science. The major issue of gender difference in learning motivation in math, nature science, and computer science was found increasing in different stage of schooling. That deserved much attention and caring from government, teachers, and parents. Finally, some conclusions and suggestions for practical applications and future researches were suggested and proposed.

並列關鍵字

gender difference ； math and science ； learning motivation ； meta-analysis ； Taiwan

參考文獻

李浩然、柳賢(2012)。國三學生數學觀念之研究。科學教育學刊,20(3), 267-294 • doi: 10.6173/CJSE.2012.2003.03. [Lee, H. J., & Leou, S. (2012). Ninth grade students' conceptions of mathematics. Chinese 267-294. doi: of 10.6173/CJSE.2012.2003.03.] Journal Science Education, 20(3),

余民寧、趙珮晴(2010)。 選擇科學職業意圖的性別差異分析-以TIMSS 2003 台灣八年級學生為例。諮商輔導學報,22,1-29。doi: 10.6308/JCG.22.01 [Yu, M. N., & Chao, P. C. (2010). Gender differences in science career-choice intentions - The example of Taiwan's eighth graders in TIMSS 2003. Journal of Counseling and Guidance, 22, 1-29. doi: 10.6308/JCG.22.01]

李美芳(2008)。高年級學生數學學習態度與數學學業成就之相關-以台北縣某國小為例(未出版之碩士論文)。國立清華大學,新竹市。 [Lee, M. F. (2008). Research on correlation between learning attitude and academic achievement in mathematics of high-grade students: A case study in an elementary school in Taipei County (Ünpublished master's thesis). National TsingHua University, Hsinchu, Taiwan.]

余民寧(2013)。教育測驗與評量:成就測驗與教學評量(第三版)。臺北市: 心理。 [Yu, M. N. (2013). Education testing and assessment (3rd ed.). Taipei, Taiwan: Psychological.]

呂惠紅(2010)。國小月相概念教學策略對學生學習成就與學習態度之影響研究。 新竹縣教育研究集刊,10,109-138。 [Lu, H. H. (2010). The effect of different instructional strategies on elementary students' moon-phase concept learning achievement and attitudes. Journal of Educational Research Hsinchu County, 10, 109-138.]