作為證物與證詞之人：臺灣當代女性官兵的性別人權困境

當代女性主義與婦女運動方興未艾，軍事領域卻因其例外屬性，長期懸置性別議題。臺灣女性官兵的發展起自民國肇建，其時以輔助與照護性軍職為主；解嚴後，國防部系統性擴展女性官兵的招募，但直至近年始開放女性官兵進入特殊單位或擔任大型、尖端武器操作。於此同時，政府單位與新聞媒體出現大量宣傳報導，其中部分女性官兵遭受歧視性角色形塑。本文從女性官兵匿名採訪紀錄切入，針對《大雲時堂》談話性節目、社群平台宣傳圖文、航太展人力部署、國防部廣告與出版著作等一系列文獻材料、事件與現象進行分析，揭露官方口徑一致的矛盾論述：一方面提倡無分性別的軍事標準，另一方面則指認性別差異並要求女性官兵自我提升。在此論述之下，女性官兵迫於彼此牽制，其專業表現被化約為個人的道德與意志問題，軍事領域的性別歧視與壓迫更遭受嚴重隱匿。換言之，臺灣當代女性官兵往往並非性別平權的實際受惠者，而是在多種公開場合被迫作為性別平權的證物與證詞，此為當前軍事領域性別平權運動的悖論與侷限。

關鍵字

女性官兵；軍隊；性別平權；臺灣；婦女運動；人權

並列摘要

Gender issues in the military are often overlooked due to its antidemocratic and bureaucratic nature. During the early years of the Republic of China's establishment, women soldiers were primarily assigned to nursing and administrative roles. Following the lifting of Martial Law, the Ministry of National Defense, R.O.C. began recruiting more women soldiers. However, it was only in recent years that women soldiers have been permitted to serve in roles involving high-tech and sophisticated weaponry. Meanwhile, governmental institutes and mass media have been disseminating a significant amount of news and propaganda that problematically portray women soldiers from sexiest perspectives. To address this issue, this paper conducts anonymous interviews with five high-ranking women soldiers to investigate a range of materials and events. These include the TV Talk show "Da Win Dining" featuring a roundtable discussion with women soldiers, the curation of the recent Taipei Aerospace & Defense Technology Exhibition, and the military government's official posts on social media and published literatures. These cases reveal a paradoxical ideology that advocates for a gender-neutral military standard while simultaneously accusing women soldiers of inherent shortcomings and demanding self-improvement. This precarious logic forces women soldiers to compete with and oppress one another, assessing their professional performances based on individual morality and agency, and seriously shrouds the fact of sexiest oppression in the military. Contemporary women soldiers in Taiwan have yet to benefit significantly from current gender equality policies, and are instead silenced and performative living proof to serve the official needs of legitimizing those policies. This paper argues for recognition of the paradox within the current gender movement and considers this impasse a potential singularity from which to envision a more egalitarian horizon.

並列關鍵字

Women Soldiers ； Military ； Gender Equality ； Taiwan ； Feminist Movement ； Human Rights

參考文獻

王淑娟（Wang, Shu-Juan）。2016。〈女性人力進用之檢討與精進〉“Nüxing renli jinyong zhi jiantao yu jingjin” [Evaluation and Improvements of the Recruitment of Women in the Military]，《海軍學術雙月刊》Haijun xueshu shuangyuekan [Navy Professional Journal] 50(4): 64-78。

張玉法（Chang, Yu-fa）。2009。〈戰爭對中國婦女的影響〉“Zhanzheng dui zhongguo funü de yingxiang” [The Impact of War on Women in China (1937-1949)]，《近代中國婦女史研究》Jindai zhongguo funüshi yanjiu [Research on Women in Modern Chinese History] 17: 158-174。

張珏、陳芬苓、張菊惠、徐儆暉（Chang, Chueh, Fen-Ling Chen, Chu-Hui Chang, and Ching-Hui Hsu）。2011。〈職場經期健康與生理假實施初探〉“Zhichang jingqi jiankang yu shenglijia shishi chutan”[A Preliminary Study on Menstrual Health and Menstrual Leave in the Workplace in Taiwan]，《臺灣公共衛生雜誌》Taiwan gonggong weisheng zazhi [Taiwan Journal of Public Health] 30(5): 436-450。

莊玲如、成令方（Chuang, Ling-Ju and Cheng, Ling-fang）。2012。〈管理性別：陽剛職場中的女檢察官〉“Guanli xingbie: yanggang zhichang zhong de nü jianchaguan”[Managing Gender: Female Prosecutors in Masculinized Organizations]，《女學學誌》Nüxue xuezhi [Journal of Women’s and Gender Studies] 30: 137-186。

陳宜倩（Chen, Yi-Chien）。2010。〈「姐姐媽媽眞偉大！」女性從軍議題之比較法脈絡觀察〉“‘Jiejie mama zhen weida!’ nüxing congjun yiti zhi bijiaofa mailuo guancha”[The Politics of Gender Equality in the Military: A Comparative Legal and Cultural Analysis]，《女學學誌》Nüxue xuezhi [Journal of Women’s and Gender Studies] 26: 135-191。

主題瀏覽