處於江右與泰州之間的儒者耿定向－一個跨越陽明後學分派畛域的人物典型

Confucian Geng Ding-Xiang between Jiangyou and Taizhou-A Typical Figure across the Boundary of Yang Ming School

袁光儀(Guang-Yi Yuan)

《臺北大學中文學報》 15期 (2014/03) Pp. 51-64

摘要

黃宗羲以江右為得陽明之傳，而不滿於泰州之流弊，其《明儒學案》將耿定向列入〈泰州學案〉，亦對之多有貶抑。但若還原史實，則知耿定向在當時與江右王門學者多所交流，如曾與鄒善、胡直等結為「心友」，而鄒德涵、劉元卿亦出其門，皆對其肯定推崇。然黃宗羲對耿定向所得泰州平實之旨，多所質疑；而對耿定向近於江右、能得陽明之旨的學術內涵，更無從正視。故本文藉由考察耿定向所作王心齋、鄒東廓、羅念菴三人之傳，申明耿定向統攝泰州、江右之學術內涵，其說之於陽明本旨，及泰州、江右學術之精神，皆可見其醇正與精微，值得後人重加表彰。

關鍵字

耿定向 ； 明儒學案 ； 泰州學派 ； 江右王門 ； 王心齋 ； 鄒東廓 ； 羅念菴

並列摘要

Huang Zong-xi deem Jiangyou School is the one who get Yang-ming's inheritance and dissatisfaction with the disadvantage of Taizhou school. His Ming Ru Xue An included Geng Ding-xiang in the Taizhou School and there are a lot of criticism for him. But if we restore the historical facts, we'll know at the time Geng Ding-xiang usually communicated with the scholars of Jiangyou School. For example, Zou-shan, Hu-zhi and he had been ＂spiritual Friends＂ and Zou De-han and Liu yuan-qing were his students. These people all praised him highly. However, Huang Zong-xi doubted the plain purpose of Taizhou School that Geng Ding-xiang obtained. He did't even pay attention on Geng Ding-xiang's connotations of academic which catch Yang-ming's decree and similar to Jiangyou School. So this thesis survey biographies of Wang Xin-zhai, Zou Dong-kuo and Luo Nian-an that written by Geng Ding-xiang to affirm Geng Ding-xiang's theory is unifying the connotations of Taizhou School and Jiangyou School. And we can find his theory in Yang-ming's purpose and the essence of Taizhou School and Jiangyou School is mellow and precision. It is worthy of our praise.

並列關鍵字

＂Geng Ding-xiang＂ ； Ming Ru Xue An ； Taizhou School ； Jiangyou School ； ＂Wang Xin-zhai＂ ； ＂Zou Dong-kuo＂ ； ＂Luo Nian-an＂

參考文獻

(1997)。四庫全書存目叢書。臺南:莊嚴文化事業公司。

牟宗三(1980)。從陸象山到劉蕺山。臺北:學生書局。

朱鴻林(1996)。陽明從祀典禮的爭議和挫折。中國文化研究所學報。新第 5 期，168-169。

池勝昌(1989)。耿定向與泰州學派(碩士論文)。臺灣師大歷史研究所。

江宜芳(1992)。明儒耿定向對王學的批評與修正研究(碩士論文)。中山大學中文研究所。