偏遠地區國民教育法令規範與政策之憲法學觀點探究－輔參酌日本經驗

On National Educational Legislation and Policies for Remote Area by Constitutional View-Reference on the System of Japan

宋峻杰(Chun-Chieh Sung)

《教育實踐與研究》 31卷2期 (2018/12) Pp. 121-151

摘要

有鑑於2017年12月《偏遠地區學校教育發展條例》之公布施行，雖可謂是已然完善我國偏遠地區國民教育發展工作推行的法令與制度框架，但於學界討論中較少有自憲法學觀點描述國民教育制度於偏遠地區推動過程時所衍生課題。故本文自相關法令規範及政策發展、該條例之立法過程、鄰國日本之經驗等面向，從憲法學視角論述於研究進程中所發現的幾則問題。經過此等探究過程，得知於該條例制定公布以前，若是採取憲法學之「立法不作為」論的觀點，則立法機關因未善盡憲法義務保障就讀於偏遠地區學校學生的學習權與受教育權，而已然長時間形成違憲狀態。於該條例制定公布後，其第二十一條久任獎金制度化的問題經過合憲性之檢視，亦已衍生有違憲之虞的法律風險。最後於參酌日本經驗方面，則發現包含制定偏遠地區學校級別標準在內，該國確實有不少作為值得我國政府機關與學界進一步深入的探究。

關鍵字

久任獎金 ； 日本《偏遠地區教育振興法》（へき地教育振興法） ； 立法不作為 ； 國民教育 ； 偏遠地區

並列摘要

This article first discusses the development and trends in the regulations and policies related to national education in remote areas of Taiwan. As regards to the development of statutory regulations, the legislative process of the ＂Act for Education Development of Schools in Remote Areas＂ promulgated in December of 2017 was analyzed and illustrated. Additionally, in light of the development of policy, an introduction of its history, recent moves and relevant opinions of the academic community are also elaborated. Second, on the basis of the foregoing, it is from the viewpoint of constitutional law that discusses several theoretical and legal issues before and after the implementation of the Act. Third, this article briefly scrutinizes the objective of implementing ＂Act on Improvement of Education in Remote Areas (1954)＂ in Japan and its related policies. It is hoped that this study may offer some insights into either education policy or education finance on how teachers from schools in the remote area of Japan are ensured to retain their position for a long time according to their willingness.

並列關鍵字

bonus for long stay ； Japan's Education Promotion Law for Remote Areas ； legislative inaction ； national education ； remote areas

參考文獻

中華民國憲法（1947）[The Constitution of the Republic of China (1947)]

王麗雲、甄曉蘭(2007)。臺灣偏遠地區學校教育機會均等政策模式之分析與反省。教育資料集刊。36，25-46。

立法院（2016a）。立法院第9 屆第1 會期第13 次會議議案關係文書：院總第1605 號委員提案第19098 號。立法院。取自https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/agenda1/02/pdf/09/01/13/LCEWA01_090113_00038.pdf[Legislative Yuan (2016a). Agenda Related Documents of Appointed Date 9, Session 1, Sitting 13. No. 1605 of Yuan Int., No. 19098 of Proposal of Bills. Retrieved from the Legislative Yuan Republic of China Web site: https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/agenda1/02/pdf/09/01/13/LCEWA01_090113_00038.pdf]

立法院（2016b）。立法院第9 屆第1 會期第17 次會議議案關係文書：院總第1605 號委員提案第19261 號。立法院。取自https://lis.ly.gov.tw/pubhearc/ttsbooki?N116280:0063-0074 [Legislative Yuan (2016b). Agenda Related Documents of Appointed Date 9, Session 1, Sitting 17. No. 1605 of Yuan Int., No. 19261 of Proposal of Bills. Retrieved from the Legislative Yuan Republic of China Web site： https://lis.ly.gov.tw/pubhearc/ttsbooki?N116280:0063-0074]

立法院（2016c）。立法院第9 屆第2 會期第8 次會議議案關係文書：院總第1605 號委員提案第19683 號。立法院。取自https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/agenda1/02/pdf/09/02/08/LCEWA01_090208_00023.pdf。[Legislative Yuan (2016c). Agenda Related Documents of Appointed Date 9, Session 2, Sitting 8. No. 1605 of Yuan Int., No. 19683 of Proposal of Bills. Retrieved from the Legislative Yuan Republic of China Web site: https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/agenda1/02/pdf/09/02/08/LCEWA01_090208_00023.pdf]