論牟宗三先生對於別教與圓教之詮釋──兼論王陽明的工夫論的別教與圓教意義

On Mou Tsung-san's Interpretation of Separate Teaching (bie jiao) and Perfect Teaching (yuan jiao) - with a Discussion on the Significance of Separate Teaching and Perfect Teaching

陳志杰(Chen, Zhi-jie)

《當代儒學研究》 34期 (2023/11) Pp. 41-77

摘要

由於牟宗三先生將圓教義理提升為一哲學系統的判教模式，但在儒家哲學中，牟先生似只以胡五峰（和程明道）作為儒家的圓教系統的代表，不免使人疑惑其他儒者的義理思想是否無法具有圓教之意義，即無法達到此一最究竟的哲學系統，如牟先生即指出王陽明的四句教只具有別教意義，似指王陽明的工夫義理達不到圓教意義，但本文認為王陽明的工夫義理亦具有圓教意義。因此，本文將主要梳理牟先生對於別教與圓教之詮釋，即如何區分別教與圓教之意義，進而嘗試兼論王陽明的工夫論中的別教與圓教之意義。

關鍵字

牟宗三 ； 王陽明 ； 別教 ； 圓教

並列摘要

Mou Tsung-san, who took the theory of perfect teaching (yuan jiao) as a philosophical system for classifying Buddhist texts and doctrines (pan jiao), primarily uses the philosophical systems of Hu Wufeng and Cheng Mingdao as representatives of the Confucian perfect teaching model. Mou's classification raises questions as to the implications of perfect teaching within the philosophical systems of other Confucian thinkers. For example, Mou indicates that Wang Yangming's "the Four Dicta (si ju jiao)" should be classified as separate teaching (bie jiao), implying that his theory of moral self-cultivation does not align with perfect teaching. However, the author argues that Wang's theory of moral self-cultivation still contains significant elements of perfect teaching. To support this argument, the author firstly examines Mou's interpretation and differentiation between separate teaching and perfect teaching, and follows this with a discussion on the significance of these concepts in Wang Yangming's theory.

並列關鍵字

Mou Tsung-san ； Wang Yangming ； separate teaching ； perfect teaching

參考文獻

一如 YI, RU 等編集：《大明三藏法數》Compilation of the Tripiṭaka in the Great Ming，收入永樂北藏整理委員會 YONGLE NORTHERN TIBETAN ORGANIZING COMMITTEE︰《永樂北藏》Yongle Beizang（第 181 冊），北京 Beijing：線裝書局 Thread-Binding Books Publishing House，2000 年。

王守仁 WANG, SHOU-REN：《王陽明全集》The Complete works of Wang Yangming，上海 Shanghai：上海古籍出版社 Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House，1992 年。

王財貴 WANG, TSAI-KUEI：〈儒學判教之基型——有關王龍溪四無圓教義之探討〉“The Archetype of the Confucian Classification of Doctrines-On the Doctrine of Perfect Teaching of Wang Long-xi's Four-Negations”，《鵝湖學誌》Legein Semi-Annual Journal 第 13 期（1994 年），頁 107-120。

支謙 ZHI, QIAN 譯：《維摩詰經》Vimalakirti Sutra，收入永樂北藏整理委員會 YONGLE NORTHERN TIBETAN ORGANIZING COMMITTEE︰《永樂北藏》Yongle Beizang （第 37 冊），北京 Beijing：線裝書局 Thread-Binding Books Publishing House，2000 年。

牟宗三 MOU, ZONG-SAN：《心體與性體》Xin ti yu xing ti（第 2冊），臺北 Taipei：正中書局 Cheng Chung Book，1968 年。