台灣近年若干重大食品安全司法判決評析

Judgment Analysis of Several Major Taiwan's Food Safety Cases in Recent Years

李忠穎(Lee Chung Ying)

《國立金門大學學報》 9卷2期 (2021/10) Pp. 75-95

摘要

近年來，台灣都一直發生多起的食品安全事件，顯示出政府的食品安全主管機關存在非常嚴重管理問題。而台灣食品安全也不僅僅是單純的執法不力而已，連司法方面亦廣受詬病。司法是公平正義的最後一道屏障，如果連司法都不能有效彰顯其公平正義的話，那立法者訂定再完美的法律也是於事無補。本文針對台灣近幾年來若干重大食品安全判決作出評析，點出其判決漏洞。司法是人民最後的希望，若司法無法有效保障公平正義，那最終將使社會和諧與人民信仰崩塌。

關鍵字

食品安全 ； 食品監管 ； 判決評析

並列摘要

Recently, there were many major food safety incidents in Taiwan, which shows serious problem with the government's food safety supervision department. In addition, those food safety issues are not just a matter of weak law enforcement, but also a big problem in judicial field. Since the judiciary is the last barrier to fairness and justice, when the judiciary neglected to perform duties, even the best lawmakers cannot help. Through reviewing and analyzing several typical food safety judgments in Taiwan, this article tries to point out some loopholes of them. Justice is the last hope of our people. If the judiciary cannot effectively guarantee fairness and justice, it will eventually lead to collapse of society and people's beliefs.

並列關鍵字

Food safety ； Food-safety supervision ； Judgment analysis

參考文獻

Brian Jack、姜雙林，2012，農業與歐盟環境法，中國政法大學出版社，北京。

丁國峰，2014，食品安全法治熱點問題探究，中國政法大學出版社，北京。

王毓正，2016，淺析舉證責任倒置制度於 RCA 判決中之適用，月旦法學，253，42。

牛惠之，2005，預防原則之研究—國際環境法處理欠缺科學證據之環境風險議題之努力與爭議，臺大法學論叢，34(3)，8。

李傑清，2015，析論食安犯罪法人所得之剝奪，檢察新論，18，119。