評論臺灣大學、清華大學與臺北大學共同出版之爭議著作

Comments on Questionable Papers Jointly Published by National Taiwan University, Tsinghua University and Taipei University

劉任昌(Jen-Chang Liu)

《科學與人文研究》 8卷4期 (2021/08) Pp. 106-133

https://doi.org/10.6535/JSH.202108_8(4).0005

摘要

當研究人員創作的論文有利用其他著作的事實，卻隱匿「被引用文獻」，而未明確登載引用之事實，將阻斷資訊的傳遞，更阻礙知識的擴散與發展。如果學術工作者不引用、不明示利用或牽連其他論文的事實，這是剝奪讀者的資訊權，也可能是意圖躲避學術舞弊爭議的指控。本文分析臺灣大學、清華大學與臺北大學共同出版之爭議著作，三篇著作取巧於量產績效，卻也因此涉入嚴重舞弊嫌疑。台灣管理學界已經有二篇SSCI影響係數大於2的國際論文遭撤除，學術舞弊是一種習性與文化，本文新揭發之案例正可以考驗國內管理學術期刊的學術誠信態度。

關鍵字

學術誠信 ； 臺灣大學 ； 清華大學 ； 臺北大學

並列摘要

When a researcher creates a paper based on previous works, but conceals the ＂cited literature＂ without explicitly publishing the fact of the citation, it will interrupt the transmission of information and even hinder the spread and development of knowledge. If academic workers do not cite or explicitly express the implicated previous works, this is depriving readers of their information rights. This kind of misconduct is motivated to avoid allegations of academic fraud controversy. This article discloses the controversial works jointly published by National Taiwan University, Tsinghua University and Taipei University. The three works make use of the same sample for studying different issues, consequently they are suspected of serious academic misconduct. The involved author has two international papers be retracted due to academic misconduct, both with an SSCI impact coefficient greater than 2. Academic misconduct tends to be a habit and culture. The newly exposed cases in this article can test the academic integrity of domestic management academic journals.

並列關鍵字

academic integrity ； NTU ； NTHU ； NTPU

參考文獻

劉任昌(2017a)。檢舉學術不端與對抗包庇惡勢的奮鬥過程。科學與人文研究，3(4)，39-62。Liu, J.C. (2017a). Challenging Academic Misconduct and Cover-up Practice. Journal of Sciences & Humanities, 3(4), 39-62. Doi: 10.6535/JSH2017094405

劉任昌(2017b)。評論藍迪斯新國富論中譯本。科學與人文研究，4(3)，44-56。Liu, J.C. (2017b). A Critique on the Chinese Translation of Landes' the Wealth and Poverty of Nations. Journal of Sciences & Humanities, 4(3), 44-56. DOI： 10.6535/JSH2017074302

劉任昌、葉馬可(2014)。論文自我抄襲之定義與性質。科學與人文研究，3(1)，35-53。Liu, J.-C. & Yeats, M. (2014a). On the self-plagiarism of academic papers. Journal of Sciences & Humanities, 3(1), 35-53. Doi: 10.6535/JSH2014123103

劉任昌、葉馬可(2015b)。引用錯誤、二次引用與對「臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫」之政策建議。圖書館學與資訊科學，41(1)，57-80。Liu, J.C. & Yeats, M. (2015b). Citation errors, secondary source citation, and policy suggestion to the TCI-HSS. Journal of Library and Information Science, 41(1), 57-80. https://doi.org/10.6245/JLIS.2015.411/646

劉任昌、葉馬可(2015c)。隱匿已發表論文以求量產策略所導致之負面效應：TSSCI期刊論文個案分析。科學與人文研究，3(3)，1-29。Liu, J.-C. & Yeats, M. (2015c). The detrimental effects of the lack of full disclosure when researchers publish in multiple journals: The case study of a TSSCI paper. Journal of Sciences & Humanities, 3(3), 1-29. Doi: 10.6535/JSH2015123301