This study explores Taiwanese elementary school English teachers' personal views towards selecting English picturebooks as reading materials for use by third and fourth-grade students. A total of 14 elementary school English teachers in Taiwan who have already implemented English picturebooks as supplementary reading materials participated in this study. Two picturebooks selected for purposes of this study were presented to the participants: Rosie's Walk (1998) by Pat Hutchins and Amazing Grace (1991) by Mary Huffman. A semi-structured interview was conducted to determine teachers' considerations whenever selecting quality English picturebooks for instructional purposes. Primary consideration was given to picturebooks as classroom materials that conformed to the regular curriculum that matched foreign language proficiency to student capabilities, that contained far-reaching content areas, and that possessed attractive illustrations.