Management fraud has been an improper and unlawful way to deceive investors and stakeholders. Two decades after the big financial scandals, the markets are still working on building back trust. Even though a wide range of literature on risk management is available, there is limited evidence on fraud risk management. The main purpose of this paper is to examine the factors that impact fraud management effectiveness. The basic argument presented is that there is a significant relation between fraud risk management effectiveness and firm value. Based on a sample of 30 firms listed in the S&P 500 index, empirical evidence supports the main assumption studied in the paper. The study implements the comparable companies’ valuation model to measure the firm value, along with relevant regulations and best practices to develop a fraud risk management index.