This paper presents both finite element analysis (FEA) and experimental modal analysis (EMA) to study three types of softball bats made up with wood, aluminum and synthetic material for their vibration properties. First, FEA and EMA are performed, respectively, to obtain theoretical and experimental modal parameters, including natural frequencies, mode shapes and modal damping ratios. Base on the experimental results, the FE model can be modified to fit the modal properties and therefore the analytical model can be validated and equivalent to the real bats. The structural mode shapes of bats are also studied to show the ”sweet spots” for better hit areas. The performance among the three bats is compared to reveal the feel of players. The validated FE model can also be applied to perform other analysis, such as impact, as well as design modification of baseball bats.