During a routine dental checkup, a 6-year-old boy's radiograph revealed 2 supernumerary teeth at the right upper jaw. The supernumerary teeth were surgically removed to facilitate the eruption of the right upper central and lateral incisors. At 20 months' follow-up, radiographic evidence suggested a recurrent supernumerary tooth. Thereafter, orthodontic treatment and further surgical removal and were planned. This paper describes the case of a recurrent upper anterior supernumerary tooth, which was not reported in the previous review of the literature.