法釋義學與法學的多元化：從《思與言》五十年所反映的臺灣法學研究發展談起

Doctrinal Studies of Law and Legal Diversity: Taiwan's Jurisprudential Development in "Thought and Words"

張嘉尹(Chia-Yin Chang)

《思與言：人文與社會科學期刊》 51卷4期 (2013/12) Pp. 199-231

摘要

本文回顧《思與言》五十年來所刊登的法學論文，指出《思與言》雖然是提倡科際整合研究的學術期刊，但是前四十年所刊載的法學論文仍以作為法釋義學的部門法學為主，近十年來則出現法學多元化的趨勢，這與《思與言》的專題化發展有關，也反映臺灣法學的當代發展趨勢之一。此外，呼應《思與言》的近來發展，本文借助德國法學對於法學與法釋義學性質的研究，檢討作為臺灣法學典範的法釋義學與其侷限，主張無論是為了克服臺灣法學目前的困境，還是為了要協助作為法釋義學的法學完成其任務，臺灣法學都應朝向多元化與科際整合研究的方向發展，在這個過程中，《思與言》對待法學論文的取向，應持續目前的走向，繼續朝專題化與多元化的方向發展。

關鍵字

法學 ； 法釋義學 ； 部門法學 ； 法律的科際整合研究 ； 法學的多元化

並列摘要

This paper retrospectively studies academic articles that have been published on the journal, ”Thought and Words” in the past fifty years. It identifies that, although ”Thought and Words” advocates interdisciplinary studies, this journal more focused on doctrinal studies of law in the first forty years. But ”Thought and Words” has switched gears and accepted diversified articles of legal studies during the last ten years. This phenomenon is related to the fact that ”Thought and Words” has adopted the special session as its focal point and reflects Taiwan's contemporary development of jurisprudence. In parallel with this phenomenon this paper also reviews the idea of doctrinal studies of law as the paradigm of jurisprudence in Taiwanand its limitation from the perspective of works that investigate the nature of jurisprudence and doctrinal studies of law in Germany. This paper argues that legal studies in Taiwan should head for multiple developments and interdisciplinary studies on law. The attitude toward articles that ”Thought and Words” should adopt is to keep its current policyto strengthen the jurisprudential diversity and interdisciplinary studies on law.

並列關鍵字

Jurisprudence ； doctrinal studies of law ； branched studies of law ； interdisciplinary studies on law ； jurisprudential diversity

參考文獻

黃瑞明(2003)。納粹時期的拉倫茲：德國法學界的一頁黑暗史。臺大法學論叢。32(5)，1-53。

Albert, Hans(1993).Rechtswissenschaft als Realwissenschaft.Baden-Baden:Nomos.

Alexy, Robert(1986).Theorie der Grundrechte.Frankfurt am Main:Suhrkamp.

Alexy, Robert(1991).Theorie der juristischen Argumentation. Die Theorie des rationalen Diskurses als Theorie der juristischen Begründung.Frankfurt am Main:Suhrkamp.

Dreier, Ralf(1981).Recht - Moral - Ideologie. Studien zur Rechtstheorie.Frankfurt am Main:Suhrkamp.