總統、國會與美國FTA政策：以NAFTA與CAFTA-DR為例

President, Congress and the American FTA Policy: Cases of NAFTA and CAFTA-DR

趙文衡(Wen-Heng Chao)

《問題與研究》 48卷4期 (2009/12) Pp. 1-33

https://doi.org/10.30390/ISC.200912_48(4).0001

摘要

在美國歷史上所簽訂的14項FTA中，NAFTA與CAFTA-DR最能展現總統與國會在FTA政策制訂上所扮演角色與影響決策的程度，故本文以此兩項FTA作為研究美國FTA 決策主體的案例。研究發現，在對外政策的決策主體的三種不同的模式：總統主導模式、國會主導模式與互動模式中，總統模式最能解釋美國FTA政策。總統具有龐大的國內外行政資源與政黨力量，可以干預國會的決策並改變個別議員的投票傾向，在不影響FTA基本內涵與目的下促使國會通過FTA。國會制訂的程序規範不足以限制行政部門的權力；除了最終的投票權，國會的影響力僅存在於洽簽時介入修改某些條款，而這些條款的改變仍需要行政部門的認可。這種由行政部門主導，國會僅能在不影響FTA 根本的前提上修改部分的條款，明顯的符合總統主導模式。

關鍵字

美國 ； 總統 ； 國會 ； FTA政策

並列摘要

Among all 14 FTA's signed by the U.S. in history, NAFTA and CAFTA-DR - selected by this paper as cases to identify the entity that owns the power of dominating the U.S. FTA policy - most represent the dynamics and impacts of President and Congress on the FTA policy formation. The research shows that among the three models of decision-making entities of foreign policy - President, Congress, and Interaction, the President model best explains the decision-making of FTA policies. President controls enormous external and internal administrative resources and party leverage to interfere with the Congress decision-making and change the voting behavior of individual congressman, resulting in the passage of FTA's in Congress without undermining its foundation. Regulations created by Congress do not generate meaningful effects on constraining President's power. In addition to the showdown on final voting, Congress' influence is only limited to slightly modifying contents of agreements mostly in the stage of negotiation, which also requires approval from the Administration. This is apparently consistent with the arguments of the President model.

並列關鍵字

the United States ； Congress ； President ； FTA policy

參考文獻

Abramson, Jill,Bob Davis(1993).Expensive Battle over NAFTA Has Each Side Claiming Its Being Outgunned and Outspent.Wall Street Journal.15,14.

Amadei, Paola(2004).Master of Arts in Law and Diplomacy Thesis.Tufts University, May.

Auerswald, David P., Colton C. Campbell (eds.),Nicole C. Rae (eds.),John F. Stack (eds.)(2003).Congress and the Politics of Foreign Policy.New Jersey:Prentice Hall Press.

Baer, M. Delal(1991).North American Free Trade.Foreign Affairs.70(4),132-149.

Baldwin, Robert E.,Alan L. Deardorff (eds.),Robert M. Stem (eds.)(1998).Constituent Interests and US Trade Policies.Ann Arbor:The University of Michigan Press.