母親因素對強暴行為可能性之影響路徑的探討

An Investigation of the Impact Route of Mother's Factor on the Possibility of Rape Behavior

黃軍義(Jiun-Yih Huang) ； 林邦傑(Pang-Chieh Lin)

《中華心理衛生學刊》 21卷2期 (2008/06) Pp. 169-189

https://doi.org/10.30074/FJMH.200806_21(2).0003

摘要

研究目的：本研究以「依附理論」及「恨意轉移假說」為架構，探討母親因素對強暴行為的影響。研究方法：以母子關係疏離、母親性行不檢、母親過於強勢、母親行為對女性觀感的影響為自變項，建立強迫女性發生性行為可能性的影響路徑模型。在受試者方面，本研究分別以371位男性少年犯和964男性成年犯，檢證所建立的模型。研究結果：母子關係疏離、母親性行不檢、母親過於強勢，均會影響受試者對女性的觀感（恨意轉移）。然而就少年犯言，母子關係疏離、母親性行不檢、母親過於強勢對強迫女性發生性行為可能性沒有直接影響，這三個自變項的影響均須透過「母親行為對女性觀感的影響」才能產生。就成年犯言，母子關係疏離、母親性行不檢、母親過於強勢對強迫女性發生性行為可能性具有直接影響，不須透過「母親行為對女性觀感的影響」的中介。研究結論：本研究就研究結果形成的可能原因進行討論，並說明研究結果的限制性。

關鍵字

母子關係 ； 母親性行 ； 依附理論 ； 恨意轉移假說 ； 強暴可能性

並列摘要

Purpose: Rape behavior is broadly studied within the recent twenty years in Taiwan and United States due to the high concern of society on this behavior, however, the perspective of mother's impact on rape behavior has not been broadly investigated by researchers. Rape is the behavior that male sexually aggresses female, and mother is usually the first female that male contacts, so mother's impact on male's impression of women is especially important. Based on the above analyses the present study addresses the impact of mother's factor on rape behavior. With the theoretical framework of attachment theory and hostility displacement hypothesis, we develop the pathways of how mother's factor influences the possibility of rape and attempt to testify the model.
Methods: Three mother variables involving mother-son relationship, mother's conduct, mother's over domination are used to measure subjects' relationship with mother, which we hypothesize will lead to the perception of mother. The negative perception of mother will lead to negative impression of woman through the processes of hostility displacement. Hostility toward women leads to the increased probability of rape behavior. The present study develops pathway model of mother's influence on rape possibility according to above reasoning. We used 371 male juvenile delinquents and 964 male adult inmates as subjects to examine the pathway model respectively. The Guttman split-half coefficient for each measurement tools ranges from .76 to .91 with content validity. Results: The present study investigates mother's impact on rape possibility with male juvenile delinquents and male adult inmates to examine the model respectively. The results indicate that there are similarity and difference for male juvenile and adult subjects. Addressing the similar part, the three mother variables all present significant impact on subjects' impression toward women. Addressing the different part, there is no significant direct effect with detached mother-son relationship, mother's misconduct, and mother's over domination on rape possibility for male juvenile delinquents, all the three mother variables have to go through ”mother's impact on the impression of women” to influence the possibility of rape; however, there is significant direct effect with mother variables on rape possibility for adult male inmates without the necessity to go through ”mother's impact on the impression of women”.
Conclusions: The probable explanations for the research findings and the limitations of the results are discussed. The limitations of the findings include whether the results could be generalized to normal individual from our criminal subjects, and the results should be limited to the premise of ”rape intention on the circumstance of no risk” because we measure rape possibility or rape intention rather than rape behavior.

並列關鍵字

attachment theory ； hostility displacement hypothesis ； mother-son relationship ； mother's conduct ； rape possibility

參考文獻

李文傑、吳齊殷(2004)。棒打出壞子？：青少年暴力行為的連結機制。台灣社會學。7，1-46。

Ainsworth, M. D. S.,Blehar, M. C.,Waters, E.,Wall(1978).Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of the Strange Situation.Hillsdale, N. J.:Erlbaum.

Bargh, J. A.,Raymond, P.,Pryor, J. B.,Strack, F.(1995).Attractiveness of the underling: An automatic power-sex Association and its consequences for sexual harassment and aggression.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.68,768-781.

Boswell, G.(1995).The Prevalence of Abuse and Loss in the Lives of Section 53 Offenders.London:School of Social Work, University of East Anglia/Prince`s Trust.

Bowlby, J.(1977).The making and breaking of affectional bonds.British Journal of Psychiatry.130,201-210.