五位台灣亂倫父親犯罪歷程之分析

Offence Pathways in Five Taiwanese Incestuous Offenders

陳若璋(Roda Chen) ； 施志鴻(Chin-Hung Shih) ； 劉志如(Chih-Ju Liu)

《中華輔導學報》 11期 (2002/03) Pp. 1-35

https://doi.org/10.7082/CARGC.200203.0001

摘要

本論文嘗試檢視五位台灣亂倫父親在犯罪歷程的幾個重要層面，並金圖連結其案發前生活經驗、情緒、認知、情境與犯案之關係，且深究他們的犯罪動機及抑制犯罪之認知機制；此外，亦探討這些亂倫者是否呈現穩定的犯案步驟與歷程。
本論文使用深度訪談，並用質性研究的方法來分析五位亂倫者以上種種層面之資料，此五名亂倫者中，三名在監，二名假釋出獄，平均年齡42歲。研究結果發現：Wblf的犯罪歷程確實提供一瞭解犯罪歷程的架構，而這些亂倫犯案亦具有歷程脈絡；在近年生活情境中，婚姻壓力與犯案動機較明顯，而早期生活經驗和犯案的動機的關係較隱含；犯案時他們多有一明顯的促發事件；同時認知結構亦扮演了促發及持續犯案的重要角色。
本研究並依據以下五個部分：⒈犯案前的事件、壓力與認知；⒉與被害者的關係、看法；⒊犯案前的情境、情緒與認知；⒋犯案時之感受；⒌犯案後反應，將五個亂倫犯犯案的內在深層動機歸納成二種型態。本文最後並對此二種型態的治療策略及再犯評估有所建議。

關鍵字

亂倫犯 ； 犯罪動機 ； 犯案歷程 ； 認知扭曲 ； 婚姻壓力

並列摘要

This study explores several important dimensions of 5 Taiwanese incestuous fathers during their sexual offence process. The dimensions includes: the connections between past and current life context and motivations of offense; the characteristics of conflicts in their marital relationships; their cognitive distortions which used to overcome their internal inhibitions, their offense behaviors, and their reactions after their crime.
Finally, this paper also try to classified 5 incest offenders into 2 types, according to their prior crime stress events, offense motives, their crime behaviors, their relationships with victims, and the reactions after crime. Suggestions are made for intervention strategies and prediction of recidivism rate.

並列關鍵字

incest offenders ； offense motives ； offence process ； cognition distortion ； marital stress

參考文獻

Abel, G. G.,Osborn, C.,Anthony, D.,Gardos, P.(1992).Current treatments of paraphiliacs.Annual Reviews of Sex Research.3,255-290.

Addison, R. B.(1992).Doing qualitative research.London:Sage.

Baker, D.(1985).Father-daughter incest: A study of the father.Dissertation Abstracts International, B.46(3),951 -.

Ballard, D. T.(1990).The Incest Perpetrator: A family member no one wants to treat.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.

Barnard, G. W.(1989).The child molester: An integrated approach to evaluation and treatment.New York:Brunner/ Mazel.