清代論詞絕句論黃庭堅詞探析

The Poetries Discuss about the Huang Tingjian's Ci in Qing dynasty

戴榮冠(Rong-Guan Dai)

《高應科大人文社會科學學報》 8卷2期 (2011/12) Pp. 265-280

https://doi.org/10.29888/KUASJHSS.201112.0005

摘要

黃庭堅詞，自陳師道以「秦七黃九」並名後，歷來爭議不斷，連帶黃詞優劣、黃詞雅俗、黃詞價值也成為詞論家討論之焦點。本文以清人論詞絕句論黃庭堅詞為研究對象，探討黃庭堅詞在清人眼中所關注之面向為何，所據文本為孫克強《清代詞學批評史論》一書所統計之清人論詞絕句資料。本文探討清人論詞絕句論黃庭堅，不採逐句逐首分析方式，乃以主題式綜合論述，就清人觀察黃庭堅詞作之特點，分項考辨，歸納並探析清人論黃庭堅詞作之共相與殊相，以見清人論黃庭堅詞之面貌，並試圖以清人論詞絕句觀察黃庭堅在清人詞論及詞史上之地位，以期能補充清代詞論研究之內容。

關鍵字

論詞絕句 ； 黃庭堅 ； 秦觀 ； 雅俗

並列摘要

Huang Tingjian's ci, since ”Hou Shan poetic theory” contrasts Qin qi and Huang jiou, has contention all the time. Along with the degree, refinement and value of Huang's ci have also become the focus of discussion. According to poetries about Huang Tingjian's ci in Qing dynasty, this paper discusses what aspect did the Qing people hold to care for the Huang Tingjian's ci. The paper is based on Sün ke qiang's ”The criticism of the history of ci of the Qing dynasty”,which gather Qing people's poetries about ci. The paper discusses Qing people's point of view about Huang's ci, and tries to establish the characteristic of poetic theory in Qing dynasty.

並列關鍵字

poetries about ci ； Huang Tingjian ； Qin Guan ； refinement