從「以我為榮」到「證明自己」：華人文化脈絡下知覺不同父母期待之大學生的生涯因應組型初探研究

From ＂Taking Pride in Me＂ to ＂Proving My Own Worth＂: An Exploratory Study of the Impact of College Students' Perceived Parental Expectations on their Patterns of Career Choices

王秀槐(Hsiou-Huai Wang)

《輔導與諮商學報》 37卷1期 (2015/05) Pp. 79-97

摘要

本研究旨在探討台灣大學生在華人文化背景下，在生涯建構之歷程中知覺到父母期待的高低及方向對其生涯因應策略的影響。西方生涯理論建立於西方社會的個人主義之上，而華人社會普遍受儒家關係主義影響，然過去生涯研究仍多以西方生涯理論為主，直接套用在華人青少年上，忽略了華人社會之文化特殊性。因此，本研究從台灣大學生之生涯選擇出發，以華人特有之儒家關係主義中父母與子女的角色義務為基礎，分析父母期待的高低，及子女是否符合父母期待方向，此二項變因如何相互影響子女的因應策略。研究方法採質性分析，深入訪談十四位性別、科系、家庭背景、目標動機不同的大學生．訪談資料經過歸納與分析後，發現以下結果：（1）父母對子女成就期待高低可分為「無所要求」型、「只求穩定」型、「成龍成鳳」型，其中，除了「無所要求」型的父母是將子女視為獨立個體外，其餘兩種都隱含有子女為父母之生命延伸之意涵；（2）子女是否符合父母期待方向則可分成符合、不符合及無關三種；（3）子女因應策略依據父母期待高低及子女是否符合父母期待方向可分為「以我為榮」型、「和諧平穩」型、「自我翱翔」型、「請您放心」型、「證明自己」型五類。上述五類因應組型可提供在華人文化脈絡下生涯輔導與後續研究相當的啟示。

關鍵字

父母期待 ； 子女因應 ； 生涯定向 ； 角色義務 ； 質性研究

並列摘要

This study aims to explore the impact of college students' perceived parental expectations on their patterns of career coping strategies under the Chinese cultural context. While western career theories tend to emphasize individual/self exploration and development, for Chinese, the construction of career often centers on making balances between self and significant others, especially parental expectations. Thus, this study investigates how college students in Taiwan perceived and responded to their parental expectations in the processes of making career choices since high school to college graduation. Open-ended in-depth interviews with a group of 14 college seniors were conducted, and the interview data were transcribed for qualitative analysis. The results showed that, first, there were three types of parental expectations, that is, ＂high accomplishments＂, ＂secured life＂, and ＂free-reins＂. Secondly, students' career choices can be divided into being ＂corresponding＂ ＂not corresponding＂ and ＂irrelevant＂ to their parental expectations. Finally, by combing the above two types, there were five patterns of these youths' career choices, including: (1) Taking pride in me; (2) Keeping balance and secured; (3) Free exploration of self; (4) Releasing parental worries; and (5)Proving my own worth. The implications of these five patterns were further discussed in light of theoretical and practical implications.

並列關鍵字

parental expectations ； children's responses ； career commitment ； qualitative research ； role obligations

參考文獻

劉彥成(2006)。明清時代大眾的功名心態。史轍。2，1-33。

陸洛、楊國樞(2005)。社會取向與個人取向的自我實現觀：概念分析與實徵初探。本土心理學研究。23，3-69。

陸洛(2003)。人我關係之界定：折衷自我的現身。本土心理學研究。29，39-207。

王秀槐(2002)。人我之際：台灣大學生生涯建構歷程之研究。本土心理學研究。17，167-242。

李美枝(1998)。親子關係的內涵與功能。心理學研究。9，3-52。