中國大陸初中生對歷史教科書敘寫的認知理解探析－以義務教育「非洲」主題為例

Research on History Textbook Narratives Regarding Cognitive Understanding in Junior High School Students in Mainland China: Compulsory Africa-Themed Education as an Example

周仕德(Shi-De Zhou3) ； 劉翠青(Cui-Qing Liu)

《教科書研究》 11卷2期 (2018/08) Pp. 57-90

https://doi.org/10.6481/JTR.201808_11(2).03

摘要

基於國家歷史課程標準需要、初中生歷史深度學習、提升歷史教科書研究、另一視角推進中國大陸非洲研究需要，本研究以中圖社2006版非洲主題為例，嘗試探討初中生對歷史教科書敘寫的認知理解情況。先運用文獻分析法對國內外歷史教科書敘寫認知的現狀進行綜述、梳理歷史教學大綱和歷史課程標準中非洲主題知識的演變系統；使用自行編制選擇題和客觀題的問卷測試調查分析法，結合教師課堂觀察及輔助訪談，提出整合分析與對策。透過採用理論與實證研究相結合的思路，希望研究結果對今後改進和提高中國大陸歷史教科書的敘寫、中學生的歷史學習以及歷史教師、歷史教學實踐方面改進等提供建議，具有重要的理論與實踐意義。

關鍵字

初中生 ； 歷史教科書敘寫 ； 認知理解 ； 非洲主題 ； 實證研究

並列摘要

Based on the needs of national history curriculum standards and history education for junior high school students, this study promoted Africa research from a different perspective in Mainland China to improve research on history textbooks. Taking the Africa-themed books of Sinomap Press in 2006 as an example, we explored junior high school students' cognitive understanding regarding history textbooks. A document analysis method was applied to summarize the cognition situation of historical textbooks and present the thematic evolution of knowledge related to Africa in the history syllabus and curriculum standards. Moreover, a questionnaire was adopted to study this theme. The research also included observation, an auxiliary interview, and a combination of theoretical and empirical research. The following research plan was adopted: scrutinize subject matter contents in the history syllabus→implement test surveys using two types of questionnaire→perform statistical analysis on the two types of results→ observe teaching (teaching process design)→analyze results→reflect on research results and countermeasures. The results of the study may provide vital theoretical and practical implications for the improvement of history textbooks in Mainland China, the history education of middle school students, and the improvement of history teaching practice.

並列關鍵字

junior high school students ； history textbook narratives ； cognitive understanding ； Africa research ； empirical research

參考文獻

Havekes, H.,Aardema, A.,de Vries, J.(2010).Active historical thinking: Designing learning activities to stimulate domain specific thinking.Teaching History.139,52-59.

Smith, T. W.,Colby, S. A.(2007).Teaching for deep learning.The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas.80(5),205-210.

Vanhulle, B.(2009).The path of history: Narrative analysis of history textbooks: A case study of Belgian history textbooks (1945-2004).History of Education.38(2),263-282.

Wansink, B.,Akkerman, S.,Wubbels, T.(2017).Topic variability and criteria in interpretational history teaching.Journal of Curriculum Studies.49(5),640-662.

上海師範大學歷史教學法教研室編(1986)。中學歷史教學法概論。上海市:上海社會科學院。