探究學生串聯電路認知特徵演化歷程之跨年級研究

An Across-grade Study to Investigate the Evolutionary Processes of Students' Cognitive Characters in Series Connection

林靜雯(Jing-Wen Lin) ； 邱美虹(Mei-Hung Chiu)

《教育科學研究期刊》 54卷4期 (2009/12) Pp. 139-170

摘要

跨年級研究有助於課程設計的縱向連續發展，但卻極為耗時費力。因此，林靜雯等人（林靜雯，2006；Lin & Chiu, 2006）建立支序分類之概念演化取向，藉電腦軟體預測學生串聯電路心智模式的演化路徑，希望能克服早期跨年級研究的缺點。本研究特別設計跨年級的調查，以電學診斷式測驗檢測三年級、五年級、七年級及九年級學生共440名，藉此獲得學生各認知特徵與狀態於各年段的分布比例以檢驗林靜雯等人的預測。研究結果顯示，林靜雯等人的預測與實徵結果大致相符，且藉由其預測與跨年級調查結果的整合，本研究清楚表徵學生於串聯電路心智模式上認知特徵演化的全貌，並解釋了學生串聯電路概念演化與課程發展之間的可能關係，初步證實了支序分類學之概念演化取向之可行性。

關鍵字

支序分類之概念演化取向 ； 串聯電路 ； 跨年級研究 ； 認知特徵

並列摘要

An across-grade study is helpful for the developing of vertical curriculum design, but it requires considerable time and manpower. Therefore, Lin and her colleague (Lin, 2006; Lin & Chiu, 2006) develop a cladistics approach in conceptual evolution to predict pupils' mental model evolutionary pathways in series connection with the assistance of the software. They hope to overcome the limitations of the across-grade studies in the early days by this approach. Accordingly, this study conducts an across-grade survey and adopts a set of diagnostic test items to 440 students from Grade 3 to Grade 9 to obtain the across graders percentages of students' cognitive characters and statuses for evaluating Lin and her colleague's prediction. The research results show that Lin's prediction almost fits the empirical data of the across-grade tests. In addition, they clearly represent a global picture of the evolutionary process of pupils' cognitive characters of mental models in series connection and explain the possible relationship between pupils' conceptual evolution in series connection and curriculum sequence by comparing Lin's prediction and the investigation results of the across-grade tests in this study. In sum, the research results verified the feasibility of applying cladistics approach in conceptual evolution to science education tentatively.

並列關鍵字

cladistics approach in conceptual evolution ； series connection ； across-grade study ； cognitive character

參考文獻

Lin, J. W.,Chiu, M. H.(2008).Investigating the influences of mental model based teaching-learning sequences on students learning in electricity.(Paper presented at the NARST 2008).

Lin, J. W.,Chiu, M. H.(2008).Investigating the influences of mental model based teaching-learning sequences on students learning in electricity.(Paper presented at the NARST 2008).

黃達三(2004)。學生動物分類及脊椎動物概念的發展：跨年齡研究。科學教育學刊。12(3)，289-310。

邱美虹、林靜雯(2002)。以多重類比探究兒童電流心智模式之改變。科學教育學刊。10(2)，109-134。

Arnold, M.,Millar, R.(1987).Being constructive: An alternative approach to the teaching of introductory ideas in electricity.International Journal of Science Education.9(5),553-563.