批判教育學在台灣：發展與困境

The Development and Difficulties of Critical Pedagogy in Taiwan

林昱貞(Yu-Chen Lin)

《教育研究集刊》 48:4期 (2002/12) Pp. 1-25

https://doi.org/10.6910/BER.200212_(48-4).0001

摘要

發展自中南美洲，並由北美Henry Giroux、Peter McLaren等人所倡議之「批判教育學」，自1980年代以來已成爲西方世界裡頭左派知識份子用以批判新右派、新保守主義、新自由主義、教育市場化的主要論述利器，同時也爲饒富批判、解放色彩的教育實踐開啟另一扇希望之窗。隨著台灣近年來政治、經濟、社會文化的急遽變遷，批判教育學在台灣也從早年不談、「諱」談的受忽視狀態，一躍而爲流行的批判語言。爲了瞭解批判教育學在台灣被引用、應用的狀況；相關研究的應用範疇、分析焦點；及其隱藏的困境與問題等。本文第一部分先從批判教育學的理論源流與發展歷程、理論内涵出發，對批判教育學的發展脈絡作一整全性的理解。第二部分筆者透過中華民國期刊論文索引系統，對於國内批判教育學的相關研究進行廣泛蒐集、論述分析，以瞭解批判教育學在台灣的發展現狀和困境，並爲將來相關研究的發展方向提出建言。本研究發現國内對於批判教育學的引介和應用有下列問題：1.見樹不見林的理解；2.理論與實踐的失衡；3.去脈絡化的批判語言；4.缺乏教師作爲轉化型知識份子的實踐性研究；5.缺乏以正面觀點看待學生抗拒的文化研究等問題，這些困境有待後續研究者持續進行批判教育學的轉化與本土扎根工作。

關鍵字

批判教育學 ； 抗拒 ； 轉化型知識份子 ； Henry Giroux

並列摘要

Since the 1980's, critical pedagogy, particularly its ideological and political aspects, has become a powerful discourse presenting a great challenge to American education. On account of its critical and liberal approach, critical pedagogy has been introduced and applied more widely by Taiwanese academics. In order to understand the application, this paper explores the development and difficulties of critical pedagogy in Taiwan. First, it introduces the background and major concepts of critical pedagogy. Second, it discusses related research in Taiwan. Finally, it makes some suggestions for further research. The results demonstrate that research in critical pedagogy in Taiwan has the following problems: 1. Critical pedagogy is only partially understood; 2. There is an imbalance between theory and practice; 3. Critical language is decontextualized; 4. Research about teachers as transformative intellectuals has been lacking; and 5. Research as to the resistance of student culture has been limited. Suggestions are presented at the end of this paper.

並列關鍵字

critical pedagogy ； resistance ； transformative intellectual ； Henry Giroux

參考文獻

Argyris, C.,Schon, D. A.(1974).Theory in Practice: Increasing Professional Effectiveness.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass Publish.

Barone, T.(1995).Persuasive writing, vigilant readings and reconstructed characters: The paradox of trust in educational storysharing.Qualitative Studies in Education.8(1),63-74.

Butt, R. L.(1991).Autobiographic praxis and self education: From alienation to authenticity-Version one.An Interdisciplinary Journal of Curriculum Studies.11(1),7-48.

Butt, R.,Raymond, D.,McCue, G.,Yamagishi, L.(1992).Studying teachers' lives.London:Routledge.

Butt, R.,Raymond, D.,Townsend, D.(1990).American Educational Research Association Conference.