從需求面探究技術學院教職員評鑑能力建立之內涵

The Needs in Evaluation Capacity Building of the Faculty in Technical Colleges

曾淑惠(Shu-Hui Tseng) ； 謝佩蓉(Pei-Jung Hsieh)

《教育研究集刊》 55:4期 (2009/12) Pp. 97-122

https://doi.org/10.6910/BER.200912_(55-4).0004

摘要

評鑑能力建立在各國高等教育機構已有二十餘年的實踐歷程，我國技術學院在當前的評鑑成果下顯示，不僅技術學院的辦學品質有待提升，教職員的評鑑能力亦亟待加強。為奠立技術學院教職員評鑑能力建立的基礎，本研究旨在建構評鑑能力建立需求量表，並調查技術學院教職員對評鑑能力建立的需求程度。經文獻分析、訪談11位專家、6位專家審查及問卷調查1,054位技術學院教職員後發現，技術學院教職員評鑑能力建立的需求，除了從文獻中所彙整的能力內涵外，尚由訪談發掘數項特殊需求；而不同背景教職員對於評鑑能力建立之需求程度，達統計上顯著水準，值得進一步探究成因。研究結論包括：一、評鑑能力建立需求量表包含「理解評鑑工作之方針」、「熟悉評鑑工作之要求」、「參與評鑑工作之運作」、以及「落實評鑑工作之內涵」等四大面向共21題項，經驗證結果模式適配情形良好。二、技術學院教職員對評鑑能力建立的需求顯著高於高度需求的程度。最後根據研究結果，提出四項具體建議以供參考。

關鍵字

技術學院 ； 教職員 ； 評鑑能力建立

並列摘要

The evaluation capacity building has been practiced over twenty years among higher educational organizations. The results of technical college evaluation in our country reveal that both the quality of educational management and the evaluation capacity of the facility need to be improved. To better build the foundation of the evaluation capacity for the faculty in technical colleges, the purpose of this study aims to construct the scale of the needs in evaluation capacity building and to investigate the demands of the staff in technical colleges on evaluation capacity building. The scale construction process includes the literature analysis, interview from 11 experts, consultation with 6 experts, and the questionnaires from 1,054 faculty in technical colleges. The results of interview indicate that there are specific needs in evaluation capacity building of the facility in technical colleges besides the capacities listed in the references. In addition, faculty of different backgrounds calls for different evaluation capacity building, which requires further investigation. The overall conclusions are as the follows: First, evaluation capacity building scale contains four dimensions. They are: (1) realizing the principle of evaluation, (2) being familiar with the intension of evaluation, (3) getting involved in evaluation, and (4) practicing evaluation management. The scale has four subscales with 21 questions. After the confirmatory factor analysis, the model fit is good. Second, the needs in evaluation capacity building for the faculty in technical colleges are much higher than the higher demand level. Finally, four suggestions are proposed.

並列關鍵字

technical colleges ； faculty ； evaluation capacity building

參考文獻

徐昊杲、曾淑惠(2008)。高職學校評鑑人員評鑑能力與角色之研究。當代教育研究。16(2)，101-131。

陳美如(2002)。當教師遇見課程評鑑：轉變與成長。師大學報。47(1)，17-38。

徐昊杲、饒達欽、黃采婕、張天民(2007)。高職學校自我評鑑能力建立策略之研究。學校行政。48，151-167。

Bagozzi, R. P.,Yi, Y.(1988).On the evaluation of structural equation models.Academic of Marketing Science.16,74-94.

Baizerman, M.,Compton, D. W.,Stockdill, S. H.(Ed.),S. Mathison (Ed.)(2005).Encyclopedia of evaluation.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.