Prior literature reveals that a CEO’s overconfidence enhances firm performance up to a point but the effect is nonmonotonic. We demonstrate the non-linearity of CEO overconfidence and show that the non-linearity is affected by CEO’s power and experience. More specifically, we show that CEO overconfidence will be harmful to firm performance when the CEO is more powerful or more experienced. Our results are valid regardless of CEO overconfidence level. Based on our results, we suggest that a firm can make CEO overconfidence beneficial to firm performance by restricting CEO duality and long term tenure.