政策論述與日本少子化對策的演化

Policy Discourses and the Evolution of Policies toward Low Fertility in Japan

鄭力軒(Li-Hsuan Cheng)

《人文及社會科學集刊》 34卷2期 (2022/06) Pp. 271-313

摘要

這篇論文以論述制度論解釋1990年至今日本少子化政策的變遷。1990年代相關部會專家所主張將少子化歸因於女性無法兼顧職涯與育兒的「兩立論述」形塑政策長期走向。2001年後隨著人口危機惡化，政策層級顯著提升，政策論述進一步演化為「工作與生活調和論述」，擴大到勞動力市場等多重領域。在長期穩定的政策論述下，實際執行高度取決於首相權力穩定性，要到第二次安倍內閣後才有實質進展。經驗證據顯示主導政策論述可能低估日本家戶結構的多樣性，影響了政策成效。本文結果顯示對政策影響的整體解釋必須納入對政策論述的方向與長期影響的討論。

關鍵字

少子化 ； 論述制度論 ； 日本 ； 兩立論述 ； 工作與生活調和

並列摘要

The purpose of this paper is to adopt discursive institutionalism to explain the evolution of Japanese policies toward low fertility since 1990. I argue that the dominant discourse formed by experts affiliated with the Ministry of Health in the 1990s has had irreducible impact on the long-term policy evolution. Between 1990 and 2001 the dominant discourse of ＂compatibility between childrearing and work＂ that attributes low fertility to the unfriendly environment for females was formed and dominated the policy field. After year 2001, this discourse further evolved to a ＂work life balance＂ discourse that had broader impacts and inspired more coordinated policy actions. However, the unstable governments before 2012 prevented the forbad Japanese government from taking more effective actions. Not until the second Abe cabinet did Japanese policies toward low fertility make more progress. ITo adequately evaluate the Japanese policies toward low fertility, the power and limitations of the dominant policy discourses should not be overlooked.

並列關鍵字

low fertility ； discursive institutionalist ； Japan ； discourse of compatibility ； work life balance

參考文獻

日文部分 NHKニュース 2003〈少子化に歯止め　次世代育成支援対策法案が衆院で可決〉。6 月 12 日。（NHK News, 2003, “Diet Voted for Laws for Supporting Childrearing,” June 12.）

NHKニュース 2005a 〈大臣•引き継ぎ 猪口担当相少子化対策仕事•家庭両立できる支援重要〉。11月1日。（NHK News, 2005a, “Minister Inoguchi: It Is Important to Support Job-Family Balance,” November 1.）

NHKニュース 2005b 〈男性の育児参加少子化担当相経営者の意識改革が必要〉。12 月 27 日。（NHK News, 2005b, “Male’s Participation in Childrearing,” December 27.）

NHKスペシャル取材班 2017　《縮小ニッポンの衝撃》。東京：講談社。（NHK, 2017, The Shock of a Shrinking Japan. Tokyo: Kodansha.）

大石亜希子、守泉理恵 2011　〈少子社会における働き方〉，見樋口美雄、府川哲夫（編），《ワーク•ライフ•バランスと家族形成》，頁 13- 30。東京：東京大学出版会。（Aishi, Akiko and Rie Moriizumi, 2011, “The Labor Practices in Low Fertility Society,” pp. 13-30 in Higuchi Yoshio and Fukawa Tetsuo (eds.), Work-Life Balance and Family Formation. Tokyo: Tokyo University.）