新一代品質報告卡設計思維－病人觀點的客製化需求資訊

New generation of quality report card design considerations - patient view of the tailored need for information

陳宗泰(TSUNG-TAI CHEN) ； 陳凱倫(KAI-REN CHEN) ； 邱銘心(MING-HSIN PHOEBE CHIU)

《台灣公共衛生雜誌》 37卷4期 (2018/08) Pp. 366-374

https://doi.org/10.6288/TJPH.201808_37(4).107011

摘要

美國雖然在1987年開始實施第一個品質報告卡，但是因為成效不彰，2010年即開始改革及宣示公開民眾真正需要且容易了解的資訊。反觀國內，報告卡雖已實施10年左右，但公布的資訊仍以專業的技術品質資訊為主，這類型的資訊雖然也很重要，但不完全是民眾就醫選擇主要參考的資訊，因此，本文提出品質報告卡成功之鏈，第一步即是要客製化病人需求的資訊，本文從報告卡成功設計的架構出發，然後詳細描述客製化病人需求資訊的重要性，以及萃取病人需求資訊的一些考量，期望能給主管機關應用參考，以及引發相關學者進一步的研究。

關鍵字

品質報告卡 ； 病人觀點 ； 公開資訊 ； 客製化

並列摘要

Although the U.S. implemented the first quality report card in 1987, due to its ineffectiveness in 2010 the country began to reform and declare that disclosed information should be truly needed and easily understood by citizens. In contrast, quality report card system has been in effective for around 10 years in Taiwan, but the disclosure of information primarily focuses on professional and objective information. While this type of information is also important, it may not completely match the main reference information for choosing health care facilities. Hence, our article proposes a chain of successful report card design in which the first step is to tailor patients' need for information. We start from the framework of successful design and then in greater detail describe the importance of tailoring patients’ needed information along with some considerations of eliciting the information from the patients. We believe this format provides some pragmatic implications for authorities and can help scholars further advance related research.

並列關鍵字

quality report card ； patient view ； disclosed information ； tailoring

參考文獻

陳楚杰、楊銘欽、林恆慶(2004)。門診病人對醫院品質報告卡需求之初探。醫護科技學刊。6，29-42。

陳楚杰、林恆慶、楊銘欽(2004)。住院病人對醫院品質報告卡需求之初探。醫學教育。8，62-77。

Bardach, NS,Lyndon, A,Asteria-Penaloza, R,Goldman, LE,Lin, GA,Dudley, RA(2015).From the closest observers of patient care: a thematic analysis of online narrative reviews of hospitals.BMJ Qual Saf.25,889-97.

Berger, ZD,Joy, SM,Hutfless, S,Bridges, JF(2013).Can public reporting impact patient outcomes and disparities? A systematic review.Patient Educ Couns.93,480-7.

Canaway, R,Bismark, M,Dunt, D,Prang, KH,Kelaher, M(2018).What is meant by public?: stakeholder views on strengthening impacts of public reporting of hospital performance data.Soc Sci Med.202,143-50.