緊急救援時期的跨部門協力：以東日本大地震為例

Cross-Sector Collaboration during Emergency Rescue: the Case of East Japan Earthquake

林淑馨(Shu-Hsin Lin)

《公共行政學報》 59期 (2020/09) Pp. 67-109

https://doi.org/10.30409/JPA.202009_(59).0003

摘要

緊急災害的發生通常有規模大、成因複雜、難以預測、機關權責不易釐清等特性，造成的損害超過所在管轄機關的能力或資源能夠因應的程度。為能降低緊急災害所帶來的衝擊，建構緊急情況下的協力關係有其重要性，但卻也受到時間的有限性、不確定性和關係複雜性等因素之影響，緊急情況下協力關係的建構難度遠高於承平時期。研究發現，日本緊急救援時期的跨部門治理，雖然對外設置跨部門整合協調窗口，但政府部門仍扮演主導功能，同時將民間組織納入防救災體系，強化災害救援的反應力。然該制度也面臨下列幾項運作困境：一是制度設計目的雖是「地方負責，中央支援」，但卻可能產生「地方無／失能，中央被動等待」的情形；二是協力對象因同屬風險共受區域，降低協力成效，而中央與地方的垂直協力默契不足；三是NGO雖是政府、企業和民眾間的溝通平臺，但異質性組織間的溝通仍有待加強。

關鍵字

緊急救援 ； 跨部門治理 ； 災害管理 ； 東日本大地震 ； 非政府組織

並列摘要

Emergent disaster generally is large in scale, possesses complicated causes, is hard to predict and it is difficult to determine responsibility. The damage is also beyond the capabilities of local authorities in terms of scope and resources. Therefore, to mitigate the impact of emergent disaster, it is critical to construct collaborative relationships. However, collaboration during emergencies is much more difficult compared with that during normal times due to the exigencies of time and uncertainty and the complex nature of the relationships. The study found that in Japanese cross-sector collaboration during emergencies, in spite of the fact that there is a single contact window for cross-sector integration, government agencies take on the main leadership role with support from civil society to strengthen responsiveness in rescue operations. However, the system faces several difficulties: (1) the system is designed so that the local government holds responsibility and the central government provides support; however, in actuality the central government could be passive and the local government disabled; (2) as the disaster affects both, both parties may fail to collaborate and the local and central government may lack synergy; (3) an NGO may serve as a communication platform for the government, enterprises and civil society; communication, however, has to be improved.

並列關鍵字

emergency rescue ； cross-sector collaboration ； disaster management ； East Japan earthquake ； non-government organization

參考文獻

桑名恵（2012）。緊急期の東日本大震災支援にける日本の NGO の外部者性からの考察。人文科学研究，8，95-108。Kuwana Megumi (2012). Kinkyu-ki no Higashinihon daishinsai shien ni keru Nihon no ngo no gaibu-sha-sei kara no kosatsu [Consideration from outsiders of Japanese NGOs in support of the Great East Japan Earthquake in emergency]. Humanities research, 8, 95-108.

真山達志（2012）。被災自治体におけるローカル・ガバナンスの確保－垂直・水平補完のあり方－。日本自治体危機管理学会誌，9，23-31。Mayama Tatsushi (2012). Hisai jichitai ni okeru rokaru gabanansu no kakuho - suichoku suihei hokan no arikata – [Ensuring Local Governance in Affected Local Governments-The Way of Vertical and Horizontal Complementation-]. Journal of Japan Municipal Crisis Management Association, 9(1), 23-31.

馬士元（2011）。建立我國救災資源調度制度化及推動落實之研究（編號：PG10002-0626）。臺北：內政部消防署委託研究報告。Ma, Shih-Yuan (2011). Jian li wo guo jiou zai zih yuan diao du jhih du hua ji tuei dong luo shih jhih yan jiou [Research on Establishing the Institutionalization and Implementation of Emergency Material Dispatch in Taiwan]. (Project number: PG10002-0626). Taipei: National Fire Agency, Ministry of the Interior.

馬士元（2012）。建立我國救災資源調度制度化及推動落實之研究（第 2 年，編號：PG10102-0333）。臺北：內政部消防署委託研究報告。Ma, ShihYuan (2012). Jian li wo guo jiou zai zih yuan diao du jhih du hua ji tuei dong luo shih jhih yan jiou [Research on Establishing the Institutionalization and Implementation of Emergency Material Dispatch in Taiwan]. (2nd year, Project number: PG10102-0333). Taipei: National Fire Agency, Ministry of the Interior.

馬晏彬、李長晏（2014）。強化地方政府災害防救效能之研究（編號：NDC-DSD102-012），臺北：國家發展委員會委託研究報告。Ma, Yen-Pin, & Lee, Chang-Yen (2014). Chiang hua di fang jheng fu zai hai fang jiou siao neng jhih yan jiou [Research on Strengthening the Disaster Prevention Efficiency of Local Government]. (Project number: NDC-DSD-102-012). Taipei: National Development Council.