透過您的圖書館登入
IP:3.91.11.30
  • 學位論文

我國銀行業盈餘管理動機、內部關聯性與監督機制對盈餘管理影響之研究

The Influences on Earnings Management of Earnings Management Motivations, Internal correlation and Monitoring Mechanisms in the Taiwanese Banking Industry.

指導教授 : 黃振豊 蔡信夫

摘要


本研究係從銀行業盈餘管理動機、銀行業內部關聯性及外部監督機制三個構面切入,探討管理當局是否有利用裁決性壞帳或買賣有價證券損益兩項銀行業常用的盈餘管理工具從事盈餘管理,研究範圍及對象以民國88年至民國97年之國內上市(櫃)及金控旗下銀行為樣本,共計24家行庫。 隨著企業營運規模持續擴大,高階管理階層的經營績效便容易成為各方關注的焦點,依DeAngelo(1988)提出的論點,外部競爭者常會以企業盈餘不佳為由攻擊現任管理階層,而現任管理當局為保衛對企業之經營權,常會藉由操弄盈餘的方式美化其經營績效,因此,經營績效與盈餘管理可謂息息相關。此外,以往學者對於高階管理階層異動議題多聚焦於與公司績效間關聯性,研究結論並無一致,一派學者認為當公司經營績效下降時,公司會以更換高階管理階層方式來提昇績效;而另一派學者則認為當公司更換高階管理階層後,反而會導效公司經營績效滑落,因為繼任者會有洗大澡(Take a bath)的盈餘管理現象。本研究於高階管理階層異動該項變數與盈餘管理具相關性時,將進一步分析高階管理階層異動與否之樣本銀行於各構面之差異性,並觀察其內部股權結構變化及外部監督機制是否能有效發揮。 實證結果發現:(一)銀行業盈餘管理動機構面:高階管理階層確有利用裁決性壞帳與買賣有價證券損益二項銀行業常用的盈餘管理工具從事盈餘管理,與相關文獻及本研究假說預期相同有買回股權、現金增資、損益平穩及高階異動四項變數;但符合資本適足率該項變數則與相關文獻及預期相反,可能因樣本銀行之資本適足率已逾法規門檻且偏高,高階管理階層便有從事盈餘管理降低過高資本適足率之動機。(二)銀行內部關聯性構面:當樣本銀行為金控成員時,因各子公司間資源較多且能分享,使得高階管理階層有利用該項優勢從事盈餘管理的情形。另外,高階管理階層雖具家族成員背景,不容易因績效不佳而被撤換,但實證顯示部分樣本銀行雖具家族成員背景,卻因案而遭解職或因經營績效不佳而遭併購,使管理經層雖有家族成員背景仍難逃被撤換。(三)外部監督機制構面:當樣本銀行公股持股比重越高,則公股代表介入董事會程度越深,越能抑制管理階層從事盈餘管理;而董監事質押比率越高時,受金融監理機構及社會大眾關注程度也越高,致使董監事股權質押比率高的行庫其盈餘管理程度不升反降。 此外,本研究進一步探討高階管理階層異動年度與盈餘管理之差異性,實證發現董事會人數多或政府持股比率越高的樣本銀行,於高階管理階層未異動年度,確實能發揮其外部監督的功能,有效抑制高階管理階層從事盈餘管理。

並列摘要


The research focuses on three dimensions of earnings management motivations in banking, bank’s internal correlation and external monitoring mechanisms to explore whether senior management involves in earnings management with discretionary bad debts or Securities Gain and Loss which are common in earnings management in banking industry. The study covers 24 domestic TWSE (OTC) listed banks and banks under financial holding companies from 1999 to 2008. As operation is getting larger and larger, performance of senior management tends to be the focus of all people. According to DeAngelo (1988), outside competitors often attack current senior management with poor profits. To defend the operation right, current senior management manipulates earnings management to make the performance better. Thus, business performance is closely related to earnings management. In the past, domestic and foreign scholars focused on business performance in issues of senior management changes. The conclusions are not consistent. One school of scholars believe, when business performance worsens, companies change senior management to enhance performance; the other hold that change of senior management only result in worse performance, as successors take a bath earnings management. This study intends to make further analysis of the differences in every dimension in the sample banks that have senior management change or not, when the variable “senior management change” has correlation with “earnings management.” also, it intends to observe whether the changes of the banks’ internal shareholding structure and their external monitoring mechanism can be exerted effectively or not. The evidence-based results have shown: (1) Dimension of the motivation for earnings management in banking: Senior management really engages in earnings management with discretionary bad debts or Securities Gain and Loss — the two commonly-applied tools for earnings management in banking; there are four variables — stock repurchase, cash increment, income smoothing, and senior management changes — similar to the ones in related literatures and the anticipations in this study’s hypothesis. However, the variable conforming to BIS is contrary to the ones in related literatures and the anticipations, perhaps because the BIS in the sample banks have exceeded the thresholds of laws and regulations and are higher; hence, senior management will have the motivation for engaging in earnings management to reduce the excessive BIS. (2) Dimension of bank’s internal correlation: When the sample banks are members of financial holding, each subsidiary is able to own and share many more resources, so that senior management tends to engage in earnings management by utilizing such an advantage. Besides, although senior management is usually from backgrounds of family members and they may not be replaced due to poor performance, however, according to evidence-based results, even though parts of the sample banks are from backgrounds of family members, they were dismissed from office due to cases or they were merged due to poor business performance. Therefore, even though the management is from backgrounds of family members, they still may be replaced unavoidably. (3) Dimension of external Monitoring mechanism: When the sample bank has higher ratio of government shareholding, the representatives of government shareholding will intervene the board of directors more profoundly and they will be more capable to inhibit the management from engaging in earnings management. When it has higher pledged shares ratio of directors’ and supervisors’ shareholdings, it will earn much more attention from financial Monitoring institutions and the social public, so that the degree of earnings management in the bank that has higher pledged shares ratio of directors’ and supervisors’ shareholdings will descend, instead of rising. Besides, this study has made further exploration of the differences between years of senior management change and earnings management. The evidence-based results have shown: In terms of the sample banks that have many more directors or higher ratios of government shareholding, they can really exert their external monitoring functions in the years without senior management change, able to effectively inhibit senior management from engaging in earnings management.

參考文獻


◆ Liu, S. Z. 1997. “The Determinants of Loan Impairment Recognized by the U.S. Bank Holding Companies.”, The Chinese Accounting Review, 30, 33-77.
◆ 蕭淑貞(2005)「公司治理內外部機制對裁決性支出水準之影響」,淡江大學會計研究所碩士論文。
◆ 陳曉蓉(2003),「臺灣銀行業公司治理機制與風險承擔行為之關係」,風險管理學報,第5卷第3期,P363-391。
◆ 黃劭彥、吳東憲、林家安(2009)「台灣上市櫃銀行代理成本與風險管理之研究」,會計與財金研究,第2卷第1期,P37-56。
◆ 陳育成、李秀英、李珮芬(2005),「商業銀行加入金融控股公司盈餘管理之實證研究」,華人前瞻研究,第1卷第2期,P25-42。

被引用紀錄


吳建融(2014)。銀行內部稽核與授信資產品質-以台灣地區C銀行為例〔碩士論文,淡江大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6846%2fTKU.2014.01238
陳彥騰(2012)。我國銀行業提列呆帳損失相關因素影響之探討 -縱橫平滑移轉迴歸模型之應用〔碩士論文,淡江大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6846%2fTKU.2012.00689
陳皇丞(2011)。金融控股公司旗下銀行子公司盈餘管理與裁量性壞帳費用關係之研究〔碩士論文,國立臺灣大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6342%2fNTU.2011.10925
吳佩芬(2014)。銀行業政府持股與盈餘管理之關聯性研究〔碩士論文,國立中正大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://www.airitilibrary.com/Article/Detail?DocID=U0033-2110201613571461
廖浿彣(2016)。從董事會特性看盈餘管理〔碩士論文,朝陽科技大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://www.airitilibrary.com/Article/Detail?DocID=U0078-1108201714032755

延伸閱讀